Elon Musk Maybe Right, Bill Gates Obfuscates When Asked If He Shorted Tesla Stock On CNBC
Elon Musk on his latest appearance on The Joe Rogan Podcast claimed he has it from trusted sources that Bill Gates has a short position against Tesla. The issue was brought up when Joe Rogan asked Musk about Bill Gates’ comments claiming electric semi-trucks aren’t practical.
Bill Gates cast aspersions on the viability of electric semi-trucks based on his belief, the weight of a battery pack needed to power a semi-truck would be so heavy, it will make such a vehicle unpractical.
However, this is not a belief held only by Gates. Following Tesla’s Semi unveiling event, several analysts, who follow battery technology and long-haul trucking, also shared their skepticism of Tesla’s 18 wheeler.
Some have even gone so far as to speculate Tesla’s long-range Semi will have such a heavy battery pack that it will only be able to carry half the load as comparable trucks.
In his response, Musk started out by saying, Tesla already has a working prototype they use to deliver vehicles. The Tesla CEO also noted they have already made many trips between Tesla’s Fremont Calfornia plant and Reno Nevada gigafactory.
When asked how big the batteries need to be, Musk said, they only need to be around 500KWh. Musk tried to put 500KWh into perspective by saying it will be similar to 5 times the battery capacity in the Model S & X. Musk also further elaborated by saying if the battery pack is used as a structural component the weight penalty will be even less.
Elon believes Gates’ comments came from his unfamiliarity with the electric vehicle and battery world. However, Musk had harsher words in response to the Microsoft CEO back in 2020. When asked about the same issue by a Twitter user, Musk said, referring to Bill Gates, “He has no clue.”
He has no clue
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) September 12, 2020
Going back to the Joe Rogan podcast, Musk also said “I’ve also heard from trusted sources Bill Gates has a short position against Tesla” continuing Musk also added “if it is true, he has lost a lot of money”
At that time Musk didn’t put forward any evidence for his assertion of Bill’s short position against Tesla. And given Bill Gates’s long support of clean energy, Musk’s accusations seemed to be too far-fetched.
Related news: Boring Company Equipment Seen In Tesla Giga Texas As New Era Of Manufacturing Logistics Dawns
Given the opportunity, the assumption was, Bill Gates will set the records straight, unequivocally say he doesn’t have and never has taken a short position against Tesla, and that would be it. However, in his appearance on CNBC’s squawk box, when asked the same question Gates chose to add fuel to the speculation by giving a none answer.
“I think what Elon has done with Tesla is fantastic, it is probably the biggest single contribution to showing us that electric cars are how we solve climate change. And now he has got a carbon removal challenge, so we need more Elon Musk’s. We need one for steel, cement, and all the different categories” said Bill Gates.
The CNBC interview then proceeded to interrupt Bill and again asked him “so you are not short Tesla, just so that we are clear”. Gates mumbled his next couple of words and said “I don’t talk about my investments but I think he should be very proud of what he has done”
What is interesting about Bill’s response is, in addition to not giving a clear answer on whether he shorted Tesla stock, he also claimed he doesn’t talk about his investments. However, at the beginning of the interview, Bill gates started out discussing his successful investments in Impossible Foods, Beyond Meat and Quantum Escape.
Given the unnecessary obfuscation and the contradictory statements Gates makes, it seems Musk’s Joe Rogan suspicion might be true.
To be clear there is nothing illegal about shorting a stock. It is a practice done day to day by many investors. The idea is if an investor thinks a company’s stock price is in a bubble or unwarranted he/she can take a position against the company that will give him/her a profit if the stock price of the company goes down.
The way it is done is, one initiates a short position on a company by borrowing the stock. After that, the investor will sell the stock at its market price. And if the investor is right and the stock price goes down, the investor will then proceed to buy the stocks back, for cheaper at this time, and return the stock to the original holder. In the process, the person with the short position will keep the difference between the price they sold the shares and bought them back.
However, Musk on multiple occasions has made clear his distaste for short-sellers. Even though there might not be anything inherently wrong with the concept of shorting itself. Some individuals try to create false negative narratives about a company so they can profit from the stock price going down.
So what do you think? Was Elon Musk right when he said Bill Gates has a short position against Tesla? Or are you happy with Bill’s answer on CNBC? Let me know your thoughts down in the comments below.
For more information check out: Tesla Cuts Model 3 & Y Prices As New Federal Tax Rebate Makes Customers Delay Their Purchases Also, see GM’s New SUV Has Better Range And Is $9,000 Cheaper Than The Tesla Model Y
Tinsae Aregay has been following Tesla and The evolution of the EV space on a daily basis for several years. He covers everything about Tesla from the cars to Elon Musk, the energy business, and autonomy. Follow Tinsae on Twitter at @TinsaeAregay for daily Tesla news.