Three months later, dealers are still asking $10,000 to $15,000 or more over Honda's suggest retail price, though patient and determined buyers have reported buying the car for as low as a few thousand dollars above MSRP. A few "lucky ones" have been able to scoop one up for sticker price.
When the first shipment of the Honda Civic Type R began arriving at dealerships, the most impatient enthusiasts were glad to be one of the first to own one without much objection to high markups. These buyers reported paying thousands of dollars over the sticker price in additional markup and/or high-profit accessories. At least one dealership in Texas even tried holding a buyer's Civic Type R hostage in the showroom for three months after purchase to generate traffic at the buyer's expense. Really?
Enthusiast forums are littered with hundreds of pages of shoppers who have reported that salespeople and other dealership employees have been spreading misleading or incorrect information about availability. Other potential buyers became angry towards dealers and accused them of price gouging.
The Damaging Cycle
The 2017 Honda Civic Type R certainly deserves attention, but I imagine Honda is very displeased with the negative shopping experiences that potential buyers are complaining about. Priced as Honda suggests, the Civic Type R is a very compelling value. Pricing the vehicle as high as 170% of sticker price, however, discourages shoppers and moves them to competing or inferior vehicles that don't have such high markups.
Such high markups at the dealer level reduce sales of the Civic Type R. Honda responds by decreasing production in order to keep inventory levels from rising too high. With less production, there are fewer Civic Type Rs available which in turn makes the car more rare than Honda may have intended which in turn prompts dealers to play up the exclusivity as a justification for continued markups. See the vicious, repeating cycle here?
Also See: The Honda Civic Has Finally Grown Up
I get it. Dealerships exist to make a profit. The problem I see here is that dealers are being unnecessarily greedy and if they continue with their current practices they may end up wiping the Civic Type R out of existence before it has a chance to bury its tires in the asphalt.
The Result is that many buyers who want a Civic Type R are unable to purchase one due to lack of availability or unwilling to purchase one due to dealer markups.
Honda Civic Economics 101
Prices increase when demand is greater than supply. As of September 2017, there are only about one or two Civic Type Rs listed for sale for every ten Honda dealerships in the US.
For decades, enthusiasts begged Honda to bring the Civic Type R to the US. Honda finally agreed to bring it to the masses. It has been reported that Honda would be manufacturing 75 of the Civic Type R per day for at least a year at the Swindon, UK factory - that's over 27,000 that Honda would like see in buyer's hands.
For now, it looks like dealers are choosing to hold on to their Civic Type R inventory by pricing them high enough to discourage buyers and instead using them as conversation pieces to generate traffic. Some dealers are requiring buyers to show up in person before they will even disclose their asking price. Getting potential buyers in their showroom gives dealers an opportunity to try and sell that person a Civic Si for half their asking price of a Civic Type R or maybe even the cool, all-new 2018 Honda Odyssey. (Did I just use the word "cool" to describe a minivan? Why, yes - I believe I did!)