Follow us today...
900 miles, a dead battery, and a New Year’s Eve rescue. Find out why this 2024 Prius owner is still smiling despite joining the "Dead 12V Club" and never leaving home without a jump box. What 5th Gen Toyota Prius owners need to know.
First, imagine you have just driven your sleek, redesigned 2024 Toyota Prius home, marveling at the futuristic cockpit and 57 mpg efficiency, only to find it completely unresponsive on New Year’s Eve with just 900 miles on the odometer. You are now the newest member of an exclusive but frustrating club of owners who have realized that even a brand-new Toyota can be sidelined by a tiny, failing 12-volt battery.
In a recent post shared with the Toyota Prius 5th Gen community, owner Shannon Longtine highlighted growing concerns regarding the 12V battery reliability of the redesigned hybrid, revealing how a brand-new 2024 model left her stranded just 900 miles into her ownership. She says,
“New Year's Eve, Toyota got me. I became a member of the Toyota Prius dead 12V battery club. My 2024 Prius had 900 miles when we bought it in November, and we are the second owners, so who knows. The Toyota dealer replaced the battery, and now I have a handy-dandy jump box just in case. She is a definite upgrade from our 2010 Prius. AND she makes me smile every time I drive her. AND yes, I am a dork.”
I have covered the automotive industry for over 30 years, and I can tell you that the "Dead 12V Club" is the most significant Achilles' heel for the otherwise brilliant 5th-generation Prius. Experts at Art's Automotive note that while standard cars use 12V batteries to crank an engine, the Prius' 12V battery's job is to boot up computers so the high-voltage system can take over, and if it drops below a specific voltage, the car becomes a high-tech paperweight. I recently reported on another owner who was on their second 12V battery at 60,000 miles, warning that the cost to replace these units is a "kick in the teeth".
The reality of the 2024 and 2025 Toyota Prius battery issues is that the 12V battery is often undersized for the massive electrical load required by the car's constant connectivity. Reports from owners on Reddit suggest that leaving the car parked for as little as 48 hours can result in a total discharge, especially in colder climates where chemical reactions slow down. I have followed several cases in which the 2024 Prius Prime was essentially "dead on delivery" due to these battery management flaws, leaving buyers feeling they bought a $40,000 lemon instead of a reliable hybrid.
Why Is Your New Prius Dying?
After three decades of testing Toyotas, I’ve seen this pattern before, but the 5th-gen Prius takes it to a new level. The 12-volt battery in these cars is not a traditional "starting" battery. It is an Auxiliary battery. Its primary purpose is to keep the computers, security systems, and the Toyota App connectivity alive while the car is off.
The problem is parasitic draw. When you park your car, the Prius never truly "sleeps." It is constantly talking to satellites, checking for software updates, and waiting for you to open the door. If you are a "second owner" like Shannon, your car might have sat on a dealer lot for weeks or months, allowing the 12V battery to undergo a deep discharge. In the world of lead-acid batteries, a deep discharge is often a death sentence. Even if the dealer "recharges" it, the internal plates are likely sulfated, meaning the battery will never hold a full charge again.
What Prius Owners Are Saying
The community feedback on this issue is vocal and widespread. On Reddit, owners are sharing their frustrations and temporary workarounds to keep their cars running.
One user on Reddit noted the severity of the situation, stating, "My 2023 never had issues until this year... given all the other reports I just said the hell with it and bought a good AGM battery instead of futzing around with Toyota," which you can read in the full discussion here.
Another owner highlighted the vulnerability of the new design, mentioning, "The 12V battery in a Prius is the size of a riding mower's tiny battery... You cannot leave accessories like the radio or lights on very long at all without depleting the 12V battery," found in this Reddit thread.
Don't Get Stranded
If you own a 2023, 2024, or 2025 Toyota Prius, you need to change your "battery hygiene" habits. Here is my advice on how to stay out of the "Dead 12V Club":
1. The "Handy Dandy" Jump Box: Shannon is right. Every 5th-gen Prius owner should carry a portable lithium-ion jump starter. Because the Prius only needs a small amount of current to "wake up" the computers, these small packs work perfectly and can be stored in the glovebox.
2. Avoid Accessory Mode: Do not sit in your car with the engine off to listen to the radio. Use "Ready Mode" (foot on brake, press start) instead. In Ready Mode, the high-voltage battery keeps the 12V battery topped off via the DC-DC converter.
3. Smart Charging: If you don't drive your car every day, consider a smart trickle charger or a battery maintainer. This is especially vital if you live in cold climates where the battery capacity can drop by 30 percent or more overnight.
4. The AGM Upgrade: If your OEM battery fails outside of warranty, do not just buy another Toyota stock battery. Look for a high-quality AGM (Absorbed Glass Mat) battery. They handle deep cycles and parasitic draws much better than the standard flooded lead-acid batteries Toyota currently installs.
Key Takeaways for Prius Owners
- Parasitic drain is real: The Toyota App and keyless entry systems are constant draws on the 12V system.
- Low mileage doesn't mean safety: A car with 900 miles can have a "dead" battery if it sat unused on a lot.
- Jump boxes are mandatory: Until Toyota updates the charging logic or battery size, a portable jump starter is your best friend.
- Warranty is your friend: If the battery fails, push the dealer for a load test, not just a voltage check.
A Glaring Weak Point
The 5th-generation Toyota Prius is a masterpiece of design and fuel economy, but its 12-volt battery system is a glaring weak point that owners must manage proactively. While Shannon is still smiling every time she drives her car, the fact that a new car owner has to carry a jump box like an emergency kit is a testament to a design flaw that Toyota needs to address. By understanding the auxiliary battery's limitations and avoiding high-drain habits, you can enjoy the "upgrade" without the New Year's Eve heartbreaks.
How About You? Have you joined the "Dead 12V Club" yet, or has your new Prius been perfectly reliable? Click the red link below to write your comment and join the community in sharing experiences.
Next Up: If you think the battery is the only thing to worry about, wait until you hear about the "Sports Car Acceleration" and the unexpected winter power loss in the new Prime. Read my full report on the 2024 Toyota Prius Prime winter performance here:
Denis Flierl is a Senior Reporter at Torque News with over 30 years of hands-on experience in the automotive industry. Having served as a professional test driver and industry consultant for major automakers such as Chevrolet, Ford, Toyota, Honda, and Tesla, Denis provides a "boots-on-the-ground" perspective that goes beyond standard reporting. Since joining Torque News in 2012, he has specialized in cutting through market noise to deliver data-backed analysis and real-world owner stories. His work focuses on navigating the transition to EVs and the shifting automotive market.
Have a tip or question for Denis? > Engage with him directly on LinkedIn for industry analysis, or follow his latest updates on X @DenisFlierl and @WorldsCoolestRides. You can also find his latest car features on Facebook and Instagram.
Photo credit: Denis Flierl via Shannon Longtine
Follow us today...
