Skip to main content

My 2019 Hyundai Tucson Has 60K Miles, and the Dealer Says It Needs a New Engine, It Was the Biggest Financial Mistake of My Life

Does the Hyundai Tucson have engine failure issues? Erin purchased a 2019 Hyundai Tucson and has to buy a new engine. She says it was the biggest financial mistake of her life and gives a warning to car shoppers. Here is what all car buyers need to know.
Posted:
Author: Denis Flierl
Advertising

Advertising

"If I can help just one person by sharing this information, it's worth it."

That's what Erin (@erinbak13) says in her recent TikTok clip. She bought a 2019 Hyundai Tucson, and now, at 60,000 miles, the Hyundai dealer tells her it needs a new engine. 

Erin says, "After I had my 2019 Hyundai Tucson for about six months, it started burning oil at a pretty high rate. The oil would just be gone every month, which is not normal." 

Before Erin tells the rest of her story, picture a 26-year-old who buys a used Hyundai Tucson, thinking it will be a great car. It's affordable, good on gas, the insurance isn't exorbitant, and she has a car payment she can afford. 

However, after six months of owning the compact SUV, she takes the car in to get the oil changed, and the technician tells her the engine has no oil left in it and that she needs to keep an eye on it and check it often. 

She starts checking her oil once a month; no oil is showing on the dipstick. Now, she has to go to the dealer and add oil to the engine monthly. She knows something is wrong but keeps driving the car because she needs it to get to work. 

However, the car finally dies on the road. Let's pick up Erin's story. 

"So, I took my Tucson to the Hyundai dealer where I bought the car, and they told me that it's normal for Hyundais to burn oil and that I would have to go to my local Pep Boys and put oil in the car."

"So, then I started doing my research and saw that this was happening to other owners. After eight months of owning the car. It still burns oil, and then one day, I was driving, and the car just shut off." 

"It was pretty traumatic."

"I was driving on a pretty busy road, and the car went into "limp mode," which means it sensed that something was wrong with the engine, and it was to prevent the engine from exploding. I got to the side of the road and got the car towed to the dealer." 

Note: When Erin's Hyundai Tucson entered "limp mode," it's a safety feature that protects the vehicle from further damage when a fault is detected, typically restricting power and speed. Common causes include transmission issues, faulty sensors, or low engine oil levels. The limp mode dash warning message means addressing the underlying problem as soon as possible, which is crucial. 

Erins' Hyundai Tucson Has Multiple Issues

"So the dealer tells me there are recalls on my car that I hadn't got fixed, I don't even remember what they were. So, they fixed the car and gave it back to me, and I'm not kidding; I drove the car off the dealer's lot, got on the highway, the car died, and went back into limp mode."

"So, at that point, I was pretty pissed, I had to get the car towed back to Hyundai, and they said that they were sorry and there must be a bigger issue that they didn't catch when the car was in the first time and now they will need the car for another week."

"They called me and told me that the engine needs to be replaced."

"Of course, I was shocked, and looking back, I was so naive because I was adding oil to my car. I was taking it in for maintenance every few months, and this can't be possible." 

"So they blamed me and said I wasn't taking care of my car."

Advertising


"They said, yeah, the engine needs to be replaced, and it's going to be $10,000 to fix it."

"So, I did some more research, and the number of articles about Hyundai engine failure and other people in this situation is unbelievable. I reached out to Facebook groups; I even talked to a news station and was doing everything I could think of. I even messaged the CEO of Hyundai, and he replied to me."

"But Hyundai did nothing, nothing to help me."

"They told me the only thing they could do was replace the engine and that it would be $10,000, which I didn't have. I have a car payment for this car; I had just purchased it. I'm 26 years old, and it's traumatic."  

"Now, I am passionate about this. If you are in the car market and considering this car, please do not buy a Hyundai."

Does the Hyundai Tucson have engine problems?

The Hyundai Tucson has been reported to have some engine problems, including engine stalling, excessive oil consumption, smoke from the engine, frequent check engine notifications, and engine failure. Some owners have also reported issues like rough idling and reduced fuel efficiency.  

Common Engine Problems:

  • Engine Stalling: The 2021 Tucson, in particular, has been reported to have issues with engine stalling, which can be a safety concern. 
  • Excessive Oil Consumption: Many owners have noted that their Tucson engines are burning oil at an abnormally high rate. 
  • Engine Failure: Some 2.0-liter and 2.4-liter engines used in various Hyundai vehicles, including the Tucson, have been reported to fail and require replacement, leading to numerous recalls. 
  • Rough Idling and Reduced Fuel Efficiency: These are other issues reported by Tucson owners, according to bulbapp.com

What Is Hyundai's Response?

Hyundai has issued recalls for certain Tucson models to address engine issues, including recalls for defective ABS units that could potentially cause engine problems, says Lemon Law 123

According to Asbury Automotive Group, Hyundai has also issued recalls for 2019-2021 Elantra, Kona, and Veloster vehicles equipped with 2.0L Nu MPI engines. 

Conclusion

Hyundai has had problems with its 2.0-liter and 2.4-liter engines used in various Hyundai vehicles. Car shoppers need to research before they buy a car. This serves as a cautionary tale, reminding potential buyers of the potential financial impact of engine issues.

Erin must pay $10,000 for a new engine in her 2019 Hyundai Tucson. It's an expensive lesson and doing research before she punched the vehicle would have saved her making the worst financial decision of her life.  

How About You?

Do you have a Hyundai Tucson or another Hyundai model and have experienced engine failure? If so, click the red Add New Comment link below and let us know.

Check out my Hyundai Tucson storyI Bought a 2018 Hyundai Tucson and After Driving It 2,000 Miles the Engine Died, Now the Dealer Refuses To Honor Their Warranty

I am Denis Flierl, a Senior Torque News Reporter since 2012. My 30+ year tenure in the automotive industry, initially in a consulting role with every major car brand and later as a freelance journalist test-driving new vehicles, has equipped me with a wealth of knowledge. I specialize in reporting the latest automotive news and providing expert analysis on Subaru, which you'll find here, ensuring that you, as a reader, are always well-informed and up-to-date. Follow me on my X SubaruReportAll Subaru, WRXSTI, @DenisFlierlFacebook, and Instagram.

Photo credit: Denis Flierl via Erin

Advertising

Comments

Mine (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 4:32PM

We had a 2017 Kia, same engine as the Hyundai. Had to add oil constantly and found out it was a common issue. Purchased from CarMax with full extended warranty, they determined a new engine would fall under warranty so that's what we did. Unfortunately, they did not install the engine properly and after a having the car in their shop for year, while I drive their loaners, they finally bought it back from me. Every time I see a Hyundai or Kia on the road, I know they're burning oil. Never again.
- Happy Traverse Owner

Jay (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 5:14PM

I bought a 2016 Hyundai with 65000 miles on it, clean as a whistle. Drove it for 2 months when my oil light came on, checked the oil to find out it was not even touching the dip stick. As it had a full service right before I bought it it was not even due for an oil change for another 1200 miles so I just thought they did not fill it properly. I added 3 quarts and went on.my way. 2 weeks later the oil light came on agian, same thing low oil. Then the engine started ideling at 1800 RPM and would not come down, very scary to drive as it would take off as soon as you let up on the breaks. Took it to my mechnic and he found metal shavings in the oil and a service bulletin about the timing sensor acting up because it eelies on oil peessure to work properly. Took it to Hyundai thinking it was under the 100,000 mile warranty only to find out the wareanty drops to 60,000 miles if you are not the original owner. Bottom line they told me 10,000 for a new engine. I owed 12,000 on the loan I took to buy it and did not want to put 10 grand into a 9 year old car so i ate the loan and bought a lexus. Ive owned hyundai's since 2001 ,owned over 7 of them. I was very disappointed in there lack of addressing the issue. I hope someday there is a class action law suit.


Advertising


Mark Gmyrek (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 5:54PM

I bought a new 2020 Hyundai Tucson. It was our third Hyundai.
At 44,000 miles it began burning copious amounts of oil. Almost 2 quarts per 1500 miles. I reported it to my dealer. They had me do an oil consumption test, which I failed.
It's important to note my car came with three (3) years of free oil changes. The dealership did all the oil changes precisely at 6000 mile intervals.
In addition the car often sputtered at highway speed, which was quite disconcerting.

I filed a claim with the Massachusetts Attorney Generals Office. Another with the Better Business Bureau. And a third claim with the Hyundai Motor Corporation for with I had a claim number and representative.
The shirt story was, Hyundai responded to no one. At 55,000 miles the car began burning coolant. We could smell motor oil each time we drove the car.

In the end, we simply couldn't trust the car anymore. We had it cleaned and detailed, and traded it in at a significant financial loss. Our new car is a brand new Subaru Outback, and we'll never consider a Hyundai again.

James Dunphy (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 5:54PM

I bought my son a used 2014 Sonata to commute to college. After one year the engine seized. I had it towed to the dealer. They informed me the engine needed replacement and it would take about a month due to the engine needing to be shipped from Korea. After a month I picked up the car and they didn’t charge me anything due to the 10 year warranty. He is driving the car today with no problems. I would guess the dealer is the problem.

Amanda Howard (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 6:09PM

This is exactly what happened to me! I have a 2015 Hyundai Tucson and at at around 126,000 miles it just died while driving it and I also had to replace the motor. Thank goodness I had an extended warranty!

Mm (not verified)    April 18, 2025 - 4:16AM

In reply to by Amanda Howard (not verified)

She should not go to the dealer for an engine replacement. A new engine costs about 3k and take about 10 hours to install. Figure around 150 dollars an hour. Then there's fluids and such. Figure 5k to replace it. 10 grand is absurd. Only the dealers try to charge that and no one in their right mind would pay it. Find a reputable independent mechanic. Actually find several and get multiple quotes. The new engine will typically have a 1 year warranty. At ten months, send your motor oil and coolant out for analysis and have a mechanic check it over to spot any problems before the warranty is up.

Warren B (not verified)    April 19, 2025 - 12:55PM

In reply to by Amanda Howard (not verified)

My 2015 Hyundai Tucson was bought in Toronto Canada and I blew the engine at 180K. There was a Class Action Suit for connecting rods so I got a rebuilt from Hyundai and they only extended the warranty to 200K. So I only got 20K on rebuilt engine under their extended warranty The rebuilt blew with only 110K on it with the same connecting rod issue. After 90 days back and forth they refused my claim so I fought because it was the same issue with no reply from them. I lost 90 days of Ride Share income and was forced to buy another car for 30k while my perfectly service car sits at the dealer. My lawyer is going after them for lost wages and the 30K I spent for another car and another engine at their expense. My case was not a RECALL it was a CLASS ACTION SUIT. Google Hyundai engine recall or class action suit and you will be blown away. Hyundai has been winning all types of AWARDS for their 2025 but will not address their past history.
Warren B

Mary E (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 7:13PM

2021 Kia Soul....similar story..Still paying on car....engine seized up on major road in Delaware. Recall on car for faulty pistons....towed to dealership....I was told the engine death was my fault because the car had no oil. $6400 for new engine...FAULTY PISTONS ALLOW MOISTURE INTO ENGINE AND SLUGDE IN ENGINE AND WILL USE A LOT OF OIL.....I have documents for 4.5 years of services charges on car

S Davenport (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 7:35PM

I have a 2019 Hyundai Sonata I bought the car brand new the car have slow down while I was driving I could not going Drive over 65mph took it to the dealership they fixed gave me the car back the problem happened again now I have replaced one head gasket, to stop oil leak, I replaced oil pan the dealership told me I had a cracked oil pan but right now my car is burning oil I just checks my oil frequently im out of money to continue repairing my problems with this car it's sad.

Joel A Chin Sr (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 8:30PM

My 2017 Hyundai Santa Fe Sport had an engine failure at 139k miles. But my engine was part of the recall,so Hyundai replaced the engine at no cost. The only bad thing was they only gave me a 12k warranty on the new engine

Joel A Chin Sr (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 8:33PM

My 2017 Hyundai Santa Fe Sport had an engine failure at 139k miles. But my engine was part of the recall,so Hyundai replaced the engine at no cost. The only bad thing was they only gave me a 12k warranty on the new engine

Mic (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 8:38PM

I have a Hyundai Tucson 2016. The engine went up. Oil burns like crazy. The dealership i bought it from has their own warranty for the cars they sell. I had to pay for an engine, but when i got it home it is making a very bad noise. So i think it will go up again, but they swear nothing is wrong with it.

Shawn H (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 8:48PM

I had a 2013 Sante Fe that experinced an engine failure at 105,000 miles. They honored the 100,000 mile engine warranty and provided a loaner for 2 months while the car was in the shop. I was original owner.

While I have heard of multiple engine failures I usually fail to hear if they honored the warranty like they did on mine. The story above does not address while the warranty was not exercised/honored.

Dianna Bowersox (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 9:55PM

My 2019 Tucson only had 51000 miles when it died on me. Hyundai is refusing to reimburse me for their defective engine. There was no recall, only a class action suit which ended up with a settlement. Another class action suit needs to be filed. They improperly machined the engine and that is what starts the whole oil consumption which leads to a bad rod bearing. The company is just another corporate bully. No owner of these cars should have to pay for their negligence.

Jason (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 10:01PM

My wife's 2019 Kona also chugged oil and required a new motor at 63,000kms , thankfully she has full extended warranty . The vehicle went to the dealer 6 times in one month . 1. The new motor , 2. New turbo , 3. ALL the coolant was vanishing , 4. The catalytic converter was cooked , 5. A horrible burning smell from the new motor and a wheel bearing , 6. Was to fix a hose left unconnected on the new motor install , to fix an exhaust leak at the new catalytic converter and to fix a coolant hose that had been pinched when the new motor block was installed . I also have two friends with Konas that have both had catastrophic engine failure at 35,000kms and 90,000kms in an Elantra and a Pallisade . NEVER EVER buy a Hyundai

J. Banner (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 10:08PM

2015 Sonata SE 2.4 L engine. Had it for almost 2 years. And yes, you guessed it! Engine failed last Thursday sitting at a red light. It's at a Hyundai dealership now waiting for inspection. I'll be taking the service records in this weekend. One thing is for sure...this is the first and last Hyundai I'll ever own!
It's absolutely insane the amount of reviews and stories like ours having the same issue yet no recall? Just a TSB? I'm willing to take the hit on my credit and let this piece of crap get repossessed if they don't fix it. If Hyundai does right...I'm trading it in immediately...but for another piece of trash Hyundai that's for sure!

Doug (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 10:10PM

Hyundai has a 10 year/100,000 mile powertrain warranty. How is a 2019 Tucson with 60,000 miles going to cost her a penny to fix when it's covered under warranty. What am I missing here?

Nolan S. (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 10:38PM

I purchased a pre-owned 2019 Hyundai Tucson with 72,000 miles on it. The engine went into limp mode as well at 78,000 miles. I had it towed to Clay Cooley Hyundai in Dallas, TX and they did some tests. They replaced my engine free of charge, they informed me that the 100,000 mile warranty is transferrable with new owners. I also believe that Hyundai lost a class action lawsuit in which they have to replace faulty engines.

E archuleta (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 11:50PM

I had a 2017 hyundai tucson and experienced the same problem with my vehicle. I had 96,000 miles. Driving home my tucson would not go over 59 miles on a highway that was 65 and over. Cars were flying by. I had to use emergency flashers just not to get hit. I was 180 miles away from home or nearest dealership. When I took it into the dealership they kept it for over 3 months. I kept asking what was taking so long. Stated that the hyundai manufacturers had to look into my claim. After 3 months. They stated it was not under warranty and it would cost me over $10,000 for an engine. I had just paid my loan off and was without a vehicle. I also tried the BBB office but no help. I would never buy another hyundai vehicle. I maintained my vehicle always took care of the necessary maintenance. The buyer is the victim not the manufacturer. Buyers beware!!!!!

Leslie Luttrell (not verified)    April 17, 2025 - 11:56PM

2019 Hyundai Tucson have problems misfiring without an engine light on. Starts and idles fine, but giving gas in acceleration the Tucson vibrates and smothers

Michael Vila (not verified)    April 18, 2025 - 3:22AM

Purchased a 2016 Tucson with 40k miles in January, 2021. No serious mechanical issues but it has experienced the excessive oil consumption issue. So, I change the oil every 3k instead of every 5k. Oil is cheaper than metal...
Have had to replace three window units that lower and raise the windows. Fortunately, I purchased an extended warranty so these were no charge repairs.
Two, perhaps three check engine light issues that were also minor repairs.

Good luck to all Hyundai owners.

Kristi (not verified)    April 18, 2025 - 3:42AM

Have owned 4 Hyundai's, first 2 got over 200,000 miles and they even replaced bearings for free at 179,000 miles. You were mislead as if your car had an issue at 60,000 that falls under the warranty. In my 3rd Hyundai, a Sonata, they replaced the engine for free at 130,000 miles My daughter now has it and it is around 150,000 and going strong. Since they've honored their warranty for me I bought a 2023 Tucson hybrid and loving it! I'm at around 43,000 miles so far.

Darren Graves (not verified)    April 18, 2025 - 8:57AM

In reply to by Kristi (not verified)

Are you saying she is lying? She was not mislead Hyundai depending on the dealer, I believe, plays games with you and picks and chooses what they can cover and what they can get out of even though their "cars" clearly have a manufacturing defect in many models! In my case they just chocked it up to I was the second hand owner so they would not cover the problem. I even talked to Hyundai corporate that gave me the run around as well. Honda never gave me such poor customer service, let alone had such a poor record of manufacturing defects. Good luck with your Hyundais, hopefully they never leave your kid stranded.