“I Put 395K Miles On My 1994 Chevy Silverado, My 2019 With 128K Already Had Engine Failure, I’m Staying Away From Anything New, and Walking Away From GM”

From 395K miles on a '94 to a dead engine at 128K on a 2019. Tanner is walking away from GM after his modern Silverado failed to live up to its legendary ancestors. Is the "400K-mile truck" officially dead? Here is one owner’s viral ultimatum.

Posted: January 1, 2026 - 8:17AM
Author: Denis Flierl

One loyal Chevy Silverado owner’s journey from a legendary 395,000-mile classic to a catastrophic 2019 engine failure has him asking one heartbreaking question: Has GM officially abandoned reliability?

Imagine decades spent trusting a brand that once built engines capable of crossing the 400,000-mile mark without breaking a sweat, only to find your modern $60,000 investment dead in the water before it even reaches its first significant milestone. It is a heartbreaking reality where vintage mechanical simplicity has been replaced by high-tech complexity that seems to have a built-in expiration date.

Tanner Thurman on the 2019 - 2026 Chevy Silverado & GMC Sierra Owners Facebook page says,

“I want to know what the most miles anyone has on these trucks with stock motor and transmission. I fell in love with Chevrolet Silverados back in 2009 when I bought a 1994 Silverado with 290,000 miles on it and drove it for years til I sold it with 395,000 miles on it. My 2019 Silverado with 128K miles has already had an engine failure, and now I’m wondering whether it’s even possible to get close to 400K miles out of these modern engines. I’m staying away from anything new and walking away from GM.”

Why Modern Silverados are Failing Lifelong Fans

As a Senior Reporter at Torque News with over 30 years in the automotive industry, I have seen the evolution of the pickup truck from a simple work tool to a luxury rolling computer. I started my career consulting for the world’s largest car brands and spent years as a test driver, getting under the hoods of everything from base-model work trucks to high-performance machines. When a loyal owner like Tanner Thurman says he is walking away from GM, it isn't just a disgruntled post; it is a symptomatic cry for help from a community that feels abandoned by the brand they love.

The tragedy of the modern Silverado is found in the gap between the "bulletproof" GMT400 models of the 90s and the T1XX platform of today. Tanner’s old 1994 Silverado utilized a basic Throttle Body Injection (TBI) system and a low-stress V8 architecture. These trucks didn't just last; they survived. In contrast, his 2019 model is packed with Dynamic Fuel Management (DFM), a system that can deactivate cylinders in 17 different patterns to save a fraction of a gallon of gas.

While the engineering is impressive on paper, the real-world application has led to a plague of lifter failures and bent pushrods. In my previous coverage, 2019 Silverado Owner Just Paid Chevrolet $13K For a New Engine, He Adds, “I’ve Been Team GM My Whole Life”, I explored how these high repair costs are forcing owners to choose between financial ruin and leaving the brand entirely.

Tanner's 2019 Chevy Silverado

Is 400,000 Miles Still Obtainable?

For many, the "400K-mile truck" feels like a relic of the past. The issue isn't the engine block itself; GM’s small-block V8 foundation remains incredibly stout. The "Achilles heel" is the technology bolted to it. The specialized "collapsing" lifters required for DFM are prone to sticking or failing mechanically, often taking the camshaft down with them.

When a lifter fails at 128,000 miles, the repair bill at a dealership often starts at $4,000 and can quickly escalate to $13,000 if a total engine swap is required. This is a staggering blow to any owner, especially those who followed the Chevy Silverado maintenance schedule religiously.

I’ve seen this frustration boil over frequently in the community. In my report, My 2024 Chevy Silverado 2500 Broke So Often, I Made GM Buy It Back; I Hope This Stripped-Down 2025 Silverado 1500 I Just Bought Is More Reliable, I discussed how owners are increasingly looking for simplicity over high-tech complexity, often opting for "stripped-down" models just to avoid the failure-prone features of higher trims.

2019 Chevy Silverado on a road trip

What Should Silverado Owners Do?

If you currently own a 2019 or newer Silverado, you are likely wondering if your truck is a ticking time bomb. Based on my three decades of experience, here is my expert advice on how to mitigate these risks:

1. The DFM Delete/Disabler: If you are out of warranty, consider a physical DFM delete kit. If you are still under warranty, an electronic DFM disabler can stop the truck from switching into four-cylinder mode, reducing the constant mechanical stress on those specialized lifters.

2. Shorten Your Oil Intervals: GM might suggest longer intervals, but I recommend changing your oil every 3,000 to 5,000 miles with high-quality full synthetic. Clean oil is the lifeblood of those complex hydraulic lifters.

3. Listen for the "Ticking": A rhythmic ticking sound at idle is your first warning sign. Do not ignore it. Catching a lifter failure before it "grenades" the engine can save you thousands in labor.

The reality of modern ownership means we have to be more proactive than our fathers were with their 90s trucks. It is a sentiment I explored when So, It Finally Happened, My Chevy Silverado, Which Has Been Meticulously Maintained Since New, Has Crapped the Bed, Dealer Says I Threw a Rod. Even the best maintenance cannot always overcome a fundamental engineering flaw.

Key Takeaways for Silverado Owners

Modern vs. Classic: The 1994 Silverado (GMT400) achieved 395K miles due to mechanical simplicity; 2019+ models (T1XX) struggle with complex DFM systems.
The Failure Point: Lifter failure is the most common cause of catastrophic engine damage in the 5.3L and 6.2L V8 engines.
Cost of Ownership: Out-of-warranty engine replacements can range from $8,000 to $16,000, depending on the shop and engine type.
Solutions: Use DFM disablers, high-quality oil, and seek out independent mechanics rather than expensive dealerships for out-of-warranty work.

What Silverado Owners Are Saying

The sentiment on platforms like Reddit echoes Tanner’s fears. Here is what real owners are reporting:

"I just traded my 2019 Chevy 5.3 (98K miles) in due to this very reason. It was going to cost $8500 to replace it. Chevy should be doing a recall on these trucks!" Prestigious-Ant6466 via Reddit

"Mine seems to have just got this issue today, 2019 Silverado with the 6.2L engine. Dealership clocked me at $4K, saying there's a mechanical misfire... I'm wondering if I get this repaired; are the rest just going to fail anyway?" underdressed76 via Reddit

"The 6.2 and the 6.6 in the 2500 are not known for lifter problems. The 5.3 is, and it is due to the AFM... Key (per mechanics) is frequent oil changes, and if possible, deactivation of AFM." FarmerAvailable1833 via Reddit

Conclusion

Tanner Thurman’s decision to walk away from GM is a wake-up call that the automotive industry’s push for efficiency has come at a steep price in terms of longevity. When a truck that should be the pinnacle of American engineering fails at 128,000 miles, it isn't just a mechanical failure; it is a failure of trust. For those of us who remember the 400,000-mile legends, the modern era feels like a gamble where the house always wins.

We Want To Hear From You: How many miles do you have on your modern Silverado, and have you experienced any engine or transmission issues yet? Tell us your story in the comments below.

Next Up: If you think engine failures are the only concern, wait until you hear about the owner who paid $60,000 for a luxury truck and didn't even get an owner's manual. Read about the 2026 Chevy Silverado Owner who says, "It'll Be a Cold Day in... You Know Where" before he pays the dealer more.

With over 30 years of industry experience, Denis Flierl brings an insider’s perspective to Torque News, where he has been a Senior Reporter since 2012. Before picking up the pen, Denis consulted for the automotive industry's biggest brands and honed his skills as a test driver. He cuts through the noise to deliver the latest auto news, compelling owner stories, and the expert analysis necessary to navigate today's changing automotive market.

Have a tip or question? Follow me on X @DenisFlierl and @WorldsCoolestRides, or connect with me on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.

Photo credit: Denis Flierl

Set as google preferred source

Automotive News

Car Questions

Pickup Trucks

TorqueNews Hot Topics

Chevrolet

General Motors

Chevrolet Silverado