2019 Silverado Owner Just Paid Chevrolet $13K For a New Engine, He Adds, “I’ve Been Team GM My Whole Life, But These New Silverados May Scare Me Away From GM”

This 2019 Chevy Silverado owner would rather put $13K into his seven-year-old truck for a new engine than take the bait on a new 2026 Silverado that the dealer tried to sell him. What would you do?

Posted: December 24, 2025 - 11:37AM
Author: Denis Flierl

2019 Chevy Silverado in the dealer's service bay

Imagine spending years meticulously maintaining your dream truck, a 2019 Silverado, only to have the engine self destruct just as the payments end. You are standing in a Chevrolet dealership service bay, staring at a $13,000 repair bill, while a salesman tries to pressure you into a $60,000 replacement that might have the same exact flaws.

Tanner Thurman on the 2019 - 2026 Chevy Silverado & GMC Sierra Owners Facebook page says he just paid the Chevy dealer $13,000 for a new engine for his 2019 Silverado. He would rather put $13K in his seven-year-old truck than buy a new 2026 Silverado.

Tanner says, “Let’s see how far this motor goes. I’ve been team GM my whole life, but these new 2026 Silverados, the dealer tried to sell me, may scare me all the way away from GM.”

The $13,000 Gamble: Why Silverado Owners Are Choosing Repairs Over New 2026 Models

As a Senior Reporter at Torque News with over 30 years of automotive experience, I have seen the highs and lows of Detroit steel. But the story of Tanner Thurman, a lifelong "Team GM" loyalist, represents a turning point in the truck market.

After his 2019 Chevy Silverado suffered a catastrophic engine failure, he faced a choice: drop $13,000 on a new heart for his seven-year-old rig or sign his life away for a 2026 Silverado. He chose the repair, and his reasoning should be a wake-up call for General Motors.

Tanner Thurman's 2019 Chevy Silverado receipt for a $13,000 engine

The Lifter Failure Crisis

The core issue plaguing the 5.3L and 6.2L V8 engines is Dynamic Fuel Management (DFM). While designed to save fuel, the complex lifters are notorious for collapsing, often taking the camshaft down with them. When this happens, the repair isn't just a simple fix; it often leads to a complete engine replacement. I recently explored how deep this rabbit hole goes in my report, Chevy Silverado Owner Says, “My 2019 5.3L Engine Is Toast at 130K Despite 3K Oil Changes - GM Didn't Make a Junk Design Disappear”. Even with religious maintenance, these mechanical components are failing at an alarming rate.

Why Not Just Buy a 2026 Silverado?

You might wonder why someone would spend $13,000 on an older truck instead of trading it in. The answer lies in Silverado engine reliability and long-term ownership costs. A new 2026 model comes with a massive price tag and a fresh wave of depreciation. More importantly, many owners fear that the "new" trucks haven't actually solved the hardware issues. If the 2026 models still utilize the same DFM architecture, owners feel they are just resetting a ticking time bomb.

I’ve documented this frustration before, specifically when owners reach their breaking point. In my article, "So, It Finally Happened: My Chevy Silverado, Which Has Been Meticulously Maintained Since New, Has Crapped the Bed," the Dealer said I Threw a Rod." I discussed how even the best-kept trucks are hitting a "reliability cliff" around the 100,000-mile mark. For Tanner, the $13,000 was an investment in the "devil he knows."

Is the $13K Repair Worth It?

From my three decades in the industry, here is my take: spending $13,000 on a 2019 model is only logical if you plan to keep the truck for another five to seven years. If you are just trying to get it running to trade it in, you will never recoup that cost. However, the current truck market is inflated. A $13,000 engine is still cheaper than $60,000 for a new truck that might face Chevy Silverado transmission problems and lifter issues before the first 30,000 miles.

We are seeing a trend where owners are opting for a "mechanical delete" of the DFM system during these engine swaps. By installing non-collapsible lifters and a custom tune, they are effectively building the truck GM should have built from the factory.

I analyzed a similar situation where an owner gave up on the brand entirely in I Said Goodbye to This Rig Today, The 2024 Chevy Silverado Checked Every Box Except Reliability, Don't Laugh, But I Went With a Honda Ridgeline.

Tanner Thurman's 2019 Chevy Silverado in the driveway

Key Takeaways for Silverado Owners

Identify the Sound: A rhythmic ticking at idle is often the first sign of a failing lifter. Do not ignore it.
Evaluate the Cost: If a repair exceeds 50% of the truck's value, it is usually time to walk away.
Consider Aftermarket Solutions: If you are out of warranty, a DFM delete kit can provide more long-term reliability than an OEM replacement.
Don't Rely Solely on Maintenance: While 5,000-mile oil changes are vital, they cannot always prevent a mechanical failure of the DFM hardware.

What Silverado Owners Are Saying

The sentiment on platforms like Reddit echoes Tanner’s fears. Here is what real owners are reporting:

"Mine seems to have just got this issue today... 2019 Silverado with the 6.2L engine. Dealership clocked me at $4K, saying there's a mechanical misfire... I'm wondering if I get this repaired; are the rest just going to fail anyway?" underdressed76 via Reddit

"2019 Chevy Silverado 1500 lt 5.3... lifter fail on cylinder 2... Drove it home Friday, took off Monday morning, lifter failure, less than 100 miles, cylinder 8... Chevy dropped the ball with reliability." Extension-Leather-51 via Reddit

"I was in the same situation... 88k miles. GM wanted $9-10k... I went to an aftermarket shop, removed the AFM, and got a new cam... It cost a little north of $5k. That said, probably never buying GM again." Broad-Focus-4152 via Reddit

In The End

The decision to put $13,000 into a 2019 Silverado rather than buying a 2026 model proves that brand loyalty has its limits. When the "Team GM" faithful start fearing the new showroom floor, the manufacturer has a significant trust problem to solve. For now, owners like Tanner are choosing to fix the past rather than gamble on an uncertain future.

Tell Us What You Think: Would you spend $13,000 to save your current truck, or would you take that money as a down payment on a different brand? Click the red link below to write your comment and join the community in sharing experiences.

Next Up: Is the baby diesel the answer to GM's reliability woes? One owner shares why he ditched the four-cylinder for the high-torque Duramax. Read the full story here. I Traded My Wimpy Chevy Silverado 2WD 2.7L For a Muscled Up Trail Boss 3.0L.

With over 30 years of industry experience, Denis Flierl brings an insider’s perspective to Torque News, where he has been a Senior Reporter since 2012. Before picking up the pen, Denis consulted for the automotive industry's biggest brands and honed his skills as a test driver. He cuts through the noise to deliver the latest auto news, compelling owner stories, and the expert analysis necessary to navigate today's changing automotive market.

Have a tip or question? Follow me on X @DenisFlierl and @WorldsCoolestRides, or connect with me on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.

Photo credit: Denis Flierl via Tanner Thurman

Set as google preferred source

Automotive News

Car Questions

Pickup Trucks

TorqueNews Hot Topics

Chevrolet

General Motors

Chevrolet Silverado