Forget the marketing fluff, nearly 600 real owners just settled the ultimate truck debate, and the "winner" isn't who you think.
Imagine you finally pull into your driveway with a shiny new Ram 1500, only to have your neighbors, die-hard Ford fans, instantly start a roast session about your "piece of junk" purchase. To settle the score, you head to social media to ask the experts, the owners themselves, hoping for a defense of your brand, only to find a brutal, unfiltered consensus that changes how you look at every truck on the road.
Nathaniel Layaoen on the Ford F-150 Owners Facebook page asks, “Okay, let’s be real and non-biased. What’s the most reliable full-size truck brand? I just posted that I bought a Ram alongside my F-150, and everyone commented on how much of a POS Ram is. So I followed that post up with this one to prove that the same people dogging on Ram also agree that there really isn’t a good answer and that they all suck in one way or another.”
The Brutal Truth About Full-Size Truck Reliability:
I’ve spent over 30 years in the automotive trenches, and if there is one thing I’ve learned, it’s that brand loyalty is a powerful drug. Whether you are a "Blue Oval" devotee or a "Silverado for Life" driver, the data doesn't lie, and neither do the mechanics. I’ve read through most of the 572 comments on Nathaniel’s post, and while hundreds of answers claim it’s Ford, Chevrolet, Ram, or Toyota, we have to look deeper. Is there one that’s actually more reliable than the other?
Here are a few of the most relevant answers from the owners' front lines, and then I’ll give you the final answer.
Jerry Sabo: "They are all junk, pick what junk you like."
J.H. Girouard: "Reliability has become secondary or tertiary to compliance... making these engines smaller, lighter, more efficient, more powerful, and inexpensive enough to purchase pushes 'reliability' to an afterthought."
Josh Dowless (Technician): "They’re all mass-produced... pick the one that’s prettiest to you and hope you get a good one."
Angel Villafuerte: "None. They’re all pretty good and bad at the end of the day."
Alan Orsak: "Most of them 15 years ago. Now none."
Thomas Hinkl: "I drive 65,000+ miles per year... They all have their positives, but the negatives far outweigh them."
The Engineering Trap: Why Modern Trucks Struggle
We live in an era where the most reliable full-size truck brand is often the one that hasn't been redesigned yet. As J.H. Girouard pointed out, manufacturers are under immense pressure to meet strict emissions regulations while delivering 400+ horsepower. This leads to complex systems such as twin-turbocharging on smaller engines and cylinder deactivation.
In my experience, these systems are where the "junk" starts to show. For example, Ford’s transition to the 10-speed transmission was rocky at best. I detailed some of these specific frustrations in my story: “Such A Money Pit”: 2019 F-150 Owner Explains Why He Is Finally Done With Ford. When you see owners walking away from a brand after decades, you know the "reliability" priority has shifted.
The Great Brand Breakdown
If you are searching for which truck brand lasts the longest, you have to look at the specific failures of the "Big Four."
1. Ford F-150: Still the king of the road, but plagued by 10-speed transmission "clunking" and cam phaser issues in the EcoBoost engines.
2. Chevy Silverado/GMC Sierra: The 5.3L and 6.2L V8s are legendary, but their Dynamic Fuel Management (DFM) lifters are a known ticking time bomb.
3. Ram 1500: Known for the best interiors and ride quality, but "Hemi tick" and electrical gremlins in the new "Atlantis" architecture haunt owners.
4. Toyota Tundra: The old 5.7L V8 was the reliability gold standard. The new twin-turbo V6? It’s currently fighting a massive recall due to engine debris and main bearing failures.
I’ve seen this play out repeatedly. I even reported on a case where an owner couldn't take it anymore: I Ditched My 2021 Ford F-150 For This Toyota Tundra, Now All My F-150 Repair Problems Are Fixed Forever, Goodbye, I'm Out (Now, How About That Tundra?). Ironically, even that "fix" comes with its own set of modern Toyota growing pains.
What Truck Owners Are Saying
Social media platforms like Reddit offer a blunt look at 2025 truck reliability concerns that you won't find in a brochure.
"Ford has been iterating on the same drivetrains for a decade... but look how many years it took for them to address cam phasers. Toyota's new trucks have been having growing pains, and it may be years before they really have all the kinks worked out." u/hardsoft via r/f150
"The GM 6.2L is just as bad... debris in the engine was the biggest coverup." u/HandsInMyPockets247 via r/f150
"If you want to be completely risk-free, a lower mileage 2nd-gen Tundra is the move. I don't trust the new turbo motors yet." u/Fappy_as_a_Clam via r/Toyota
The Final Answer: Which One Should You Buy?
After my 30 years of experience and 572 owner responses, the "final answer" is a bitter pill: There is no "perfect" truck. In today's market, reliability is less about the badge on the grille and more about how much complexity you are willing to manage.
If you want the best odds, go for the most "proven" configuration. For Ford, that’s often the 2.7L EcoBoost or the 5.0L V8, with a strict 5,000-mile oil-change interval. For Chevy, it’s disabling the DFM system. For Ram, it’s staying away from the first year of any new electrical update. I recently covered a nightmare scenario regarding these new tech-heavy trucks: A truck buyer grew up believing that Ford stood for "Found On Road Dead," but this fleet expert just bought a 2021 F-150. Why did he rule out Ram, Chevy, and Toyota? He explains why the F-150 is the "lesser headache" and why he chose it.
Key Takeaways For Truck Buyers
- Complexity is the Enemy: Modern emissions and tech have made all trucks less reliable than their 15-year-old predecessors.
- Maintenance is Non-Negotiable: Forget the "10,000-mile" oil change intervals; 5,000 miles is the sweet spot for modern turbos.
- Pick Your Poison: Every brand has a "known" failure point. Choose the one you are most comfortable fixing or warranting.
- The "Golden Era" is Over: Trucks built after 2021 face unprecedented quality control challenges across the board.
What's The Final Verdict?
The debate over the most reliable full-size truck brand has shifted from "which brand is better" to "which brand has the fewest deal-breakers." Whether it's Ford's transmission, Chevy's lifters, or Toyota's main bearings, every owner is essentially rolling the dice. The best strategy is to buy based on your specific needs, maintain the vehicle religiously, and always keep a backup plan (or a good warranty) in your glove box.
Now, It's Your Turn: Have you experienced a major mechanical failure on a truck with less than 50,000 miles? Which brand has earned or lost your trust in the last five years? Click the red link below to write your comment and join the community in sharing experiences.
Next Up: Think your F-150's oil change schedule is fine? Think again. Check out my report on why some owners are being called "crazy" for their maintenance habits: They Said I Was Crazy For Changing My Ford F-150's Oil Every 10K Miles Since It Was New, But They Were Wrong
With over 30 years of industry experience, Denis Flierl brings an insider’s perspective to Torque News, where he has been a Senior Reporter since 2012. Before picking up the pen, Denis consulted for the automotive industry's biggest brands and honed his skills as a test driver. He cuts through the noise to deliver the latest auto news, compelling owner stories, and the expert analysis necessary to navigate today's changing automotive market.
Have a tip or question? Follow me on X @DenisFlierl and @WorldsCoolestRides, or connect with me on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.
Photo credit: Denis Flierl
Set Torque News as Preferred Source on Google
Comments
I have a fleet of well over…
Permalink
I have a fleet of well over 20” trucks and vans and we the rams, f150s silverados heck we even have a couple trucks . The most reliable and have the least issues are our Nissan Trucks. Not the the cars the Sentra made it about 6 months. The Nissan trucks have been solid and I have frontiers with 350k plus. I noticed Nissan wasn’t mentioned their full size titan is a beast and we just traded in 6 titans with 300k plus for new titans. You folks have dropped the ball on not even throwing that name out there. Other than that yeah all the new trucks are junk and any car salesman that disagrees just wants to get in your wallet.
So a group of Ford owners…
Permalink
So a group of Ford owners chose the F150 as their favorite truck, who would've seen that coming? From all my years of experience driving and working on them, and the opinion of every mechanic I have ever met, Ford is the worst car company on the planet, worse than Kia/Hyundai even. Not saying that GM and Dodge are any good, just stating that Ford is definitely the worst. As for Toyota, I wouldn't buy one.
Dude, stop telling people…
Permalink
In reply to So a group of Ford owners… by Rem Alavard (not verified)
Dude, stop telling people about the titans, I like to buy em cheap.
I have had Ford F150's and…
Permalink
In reply to So a group of Ford owners… by Rem Alavard (not verified)
I have had Ford F150's and Chevy Silverado. At 36,300 miles the transmission failed in the 2007 Chevy. The second Chevy I have owned where the transmission failed before 37000 miles. 3 F150's. Over 200,000 on one and no issues, over 150,000 miles on one and no issues. The first one had over 535,000 miles and no issues. I may just be lucky but I will have to stick with Ford's.
If I was attempting to make…
Permalink
If I was attempting to make a good light truck model, I would start by having the design team look at Chevy, Dodge, & Fords from 1975 to 1978. Sure there were some mistakes, but there were examples like my 1978 Ford E150 3/4 ton van with a 351W, 4 speed manual trans, and 9inch. I added 411 gearing, switched to a single piece drive shaft, and a Volvo 740 drivers seat. And it has been a great power tool for decades, except that my two Tesla neighbor badly vandalized it after repeatedly claiming that I was "killing the environment with that crappy old Ford". [one of his Tesla only lasted five years, due to the cost of repairs & service...]
I would also make sure that actual contractors, delivery companies, disabled patient transport companies, farmers, ranchers, etc. on the design team. People who actually use full size trucks and vans.
I suspect that offering Natural Gas & Propane versions would address the emissions without making an overly complex engine. An electric version without the complexity would also make sense for applications that usually travel less than 100 miles a day, as the fuel & maintenance costs will be worth the $10,000 for the option.
The opposed piston compression ignition engine would be worth having with a turbo & small supercharger as this design requires a compressor just to start. While complex, this design uses about 70% of the fuel of a comparable internal engine, but needs the bugs worked out.
And lastly, Ford's aluminium body is great start but it still needs a hot dipped galvanized frame...
For 2026, Ram's 10 year 160…
Permalink
For 2026, Ram's 10 year 160,000 km (100,000 mile) powertrain warranty made it a simple choice for me.
Interesting, ram is actually…
Permalink
Interesting, ram is actually known for the worst quality interiors and this article says they're the best, ha
Blue Oval since the 70's. 3…
Permalink
Blue Oval since the 70's.
3 months and 7500 miles ago bought my first bow tie ever! 3 liter duramax.
Still in the honeymoon phase, but it's a fantastic truck, SO FAR.
Right bow, I would argue it…
Permalink
Right bow, I would argue it is ram. The hemi is well proven. Yeah, hemi tick is real, but it's most common in engines that idled a ton. It's also not that common in the big picture, there are a LOT of hemis on the road. The 3.0 isn't having widespread issues either. But the real difference maker is the transmission. The ZF 8 speed. It's great compared to the GM and ford 10 speeds and the GM 8 speed. I'd argue Ford has the best engines these days with the 2.7 and 5.0 both being very well regarded overall, but then they're paired with that 10 speed. The 2.7 turbomax is Chevy's best engine, and it gets the garbage 8 speed.
I have a 2012 Ram 1500 hemi…
Permalink
I have a 2012 Ram 1500 hemi V8,bought it in February of 2013 with 6000 miles on it. It runs just as good as it did in 2013. It have 155000 miles on it now. Change the oil every 5000 miles. Change the plugs and coils at 150000 miles, there were no issues, not one issue. Love it. Looked at the 2026 engine and just too much stuff under there. Not a fan of turbo. All that new tech is going to be costly, I will wait a couple more years to see how the new ram V8 fares.
GM seems to have forgotten…
Permalink
GM seems to have forgotten how to build a small block. They have been having lifter problems since 2007. Their 8 speed. Transmission is a disaster. Their A/C systems are unreliable, and even their other automatic transmissions are problematic.
As a former Ford senior…
Permalink
As a former Ford senior master I can say with confidence that every brand sucks. Go with what you like/know and do research into what powertrains to avoid. We live in the age of predatory engineering where things are designed to last through the warranty period. Ford lost me with the "upgraded" belt driven oil pump on the coyote. I am sure that will end well.
Unfortunately, every comment…
Permalink
Unfortunately, every comment mentioned in the article is correct, none are considered reliable anymore. Which is why my most recent new truck purchase was a 2025 Silverado 2500 ZR2 with the 6.6L gas engine. No DFM/AFM, no auto start-stop, cast iron block, forged rods and crank. The engine is built to work and to last. Yes, I sacrificed some fuel mileage compared to a 1500, but it's a truck, if you're worried about fuel economy, buy a Civic not a truck.
I know I can tow or haul anything I will ever have the need to. Love the truck and no regrets, actually, best decision I could have made.
To clear any questions, this is also my primary vehicle for daily driving.
Last Chevy I owned was a…
Permalink
Last Chevy I owned was a 2011 3500 bought.new. 35k miles in, I loved the chassis, hated the detonation sensor that created problems under load. Been driving RAM since. Currently have a new '24 Tradesman 3500 with Cummins, CC, and 8' bed. Thus far at 17k miles, no hiccups or stumbles. Prior new '20 RAM 2500 same configuration, went 44k before trading, in no hiccups, stumbles or failures. It even had the dreaded cp4 fuel pump. The pump never failed, but was replaced under warranty. Both were used for towing a 15k to 17k RV 4 to 5 times minimum yearly. I find the troubles in GM and Ford trucks a good reason to stay with RAM. Obsolescence is being built into trucks now. Seeing a 15 year old truck still in service is rarity these days. It used to be the norm.
Older trucks are the most…
Permalink
Older trucks are the most reliable! Chevy, before 2006.
Ford, as long as it's the 5.0L.
And new-er Rams, 2011-2018.
The cylinder deactivation and start/stop technology turns them all to junk. Stupidest ideas ever.
My f150 has 550000 thousand…
Permalink
My f150 has 550000 thousand kilometers which I never changed oil before 10000 kilometers more likely around 20000 km engine Ann transmission works perfect but had to change the actuators 4 times
My 2021 Ram (bought used in…
Permalink
My 2021 Ram (bought used in 2024 with 15k miles on it-now 44k) is having cam lobe issues that may require extensive engine repair. It's currently been at the shop since 12/17/25.
I bought a new 2013 F150, 5…
Permalink
I bought a new 2013 F150, 5.0 with 82 miles on it, today it turned over 431,000 on the same coyote engine. Transmission was charged out at about 200,000+ miles. Oil is changed every 4k+/- miles with only ford oil & filter. Yes I’ve replace a lot of maintenance parts over the years and miles but those parts always wear out on any vehicle especially with the high miles. Engine still runs strong, plugs are always clean when replaced (on 3rd set of plugs) Looking a new truck but can’t justify $75k for a new one don’t think I get twice the truck for twice the money. Plus 10 speed trans has to many issues and eco boost not interested step on the gas at 70 mph and you’ll know why, power not there. Going to see if she’ll make it to 500,000 miles
Toyota Thunder 2016 100,000…
Permalink
Toyota Thunder 2016 100,000 miles not a single problem. Changed my motor oil every 7000 miles. When I bought new I flush all the new oil and fill with synthetic fluid.
I bought my new 2022 F-150…
Permalink
I bought my new 2022 F-150 Platinum Powerboost in December, 2022. I have 48,000 miles on it now and have had absolutely no problems with my truck. I bought this Ford truck because my husband had a 2017 F-350 diesel truck that we traded in in 2024 with 175,000 miles and had virtually no trouble with it. My only concern is the possible battery replacement, which may be in as little as 100,000 miles. I’ll just tuck that in the back of my mind and maintain a service warranty, which btw I have a 100,000 warranty already. I never buy a new vehicle without a 100,000 mile warranty.