Skip to main content

Environmental Groups With Dubious Ties To ICE OEMs Drop Their Legal Action Against Tesla Giga Berlin

Two environmental groups, Nabu and Green League, say they will not take their fight against Giga Berlin to a higher court. However, the environmental organizations vow to keep their fight.


Tesla’s Giga Berlin construction is currently taking place with temporary permits. These temporary permits are granted for specific milestones in the construction process.

However, by the end, if Tesla fails to obtain a final permit, then the EV maker will be forced to halt construction and dismantle the factory at its own cost.

As of writing, Tesla has yet to receive the final permit that will allow the EV maker to begin volume production. Elon Musk hopes Tesla will be granted the final permit in October.

Of the temporary permits, the latest one was a decision by the Brandenburg State Environmental Agency to allow Tesla to begin testing production subsystems.

Related news: Tesla Restarts Model 3 Production After A Brief Shutdown But In Limited Quantity

This has raised criticism by German environmental groups opposed to the Giga Berlin construction.

Two environmental groups, Brandenburg Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (Nabu) and Green League, specifically want the pre-approval of a functional test of the Tesla factory, issued by the State Environment Agency, to be halted until the final permit is issued.

Jörg Steinbach, Brandenburg State's Economic Minister has questioned Green League’s motivation behind the environmental objection.

Steinbach in an interview said, “I think it is questionable what justification a Bavarian environmental organization here in Brandenburg has to campaign against the Tesla settlement.”

Bavaria is home to some of Germany’s largest automakers such as BMW, Mercedes-Benz, and Audi. Steinbach didn’t make the direct correlation with the German automakers but left it with a question mark.

Related news: How Safe are Tesla Vehicles Compared to Other Auto Makers?

Nabu and Green League have criticized Brandenburg Environment Minister Axel Vogel for handing out temporary permits that allow Tesla to start testing systems functionality of the paint shop, body shop, and the installation of tanks for wastewater treatment and the refueling system.

However, at the time Axel Vogel, speaking at an environmental conference hosted by the Brandenburg Chambers of Commerce and Industry, dismissed the environmental organizations’ concerns.

Vogel said "We are convinced that it is right to give Tesla preferential treatment," because Tesla’s settlement in the area will have an "incredibly positive Europe-wide impact."

Vogel believes Giga Berlin will play a significant role in accelerating the adoption of electric vehicles in Europe saying "We will now see that the switch to electromobility is much faster than we would have thought a few years ago."

Related news: Elon Musk Says Refreshed Tesla Model Y ‘Will Be Most Advanced With 2/3 Of Body Cast’

Unsatisfied with Vogel’s response the environmental organizations filed an objection with the Brandenburg State Environmental Agency and proceeded to sue to stop Giga Berlin’s construction until the final permit is granted.

The lawsuit was heard by the courts. However, the judges ruled in Tesla’s favor. This led the environmental groups to object to a higher court which also ruled in Tesla’s favor.

According to the German legal system the environmental organizations have the right to file their objection to the Federal Constitutional Court. However, according to managing directors of both organizations, they have decided to stop their legal battle against Tesla, at least for the moment.

In a statement to Business Insider, the environmental groups said the reason they have decided to halt their legal action is “the strong mismatch between costs and benefits”.

Related news: Tesla Autopilot Crashes Under Investigation - What's Really Going On

The environmental groups still believe they have a fair chance of winning before the Constitutional Court, however, they have found the costs to launch such legal actions prohibitively expensive.

Still, the environmental groups vow to continue their fight against Giga Berlin. NABU and Green League say they will file a new objection to the addition of a battery plant to Giga Berlin.

We will keep you posted if we receive more information regarding the environmental groups’ continued protest. Make sure to visit our site regularly for the latest updates.

So what do you think? Do you believe the environmental groups’ objection to Giga Berlin is in good faith? Let me know your thoughts down in the comments below.

For more information check out: Tesla Notifies Model X Plaid Reservation Holders To ‘Prepare For Delivery’ Also, see Consumer Reports Expresses Doubts About Tesla Cybertruck While Some Businesses Are Counting On It

Tinsae Aregay has been following Tesla and The evolution of the EV space on a daily basis for several years. He covers everything about Tesla from the cars to Elon Musk, the energy business, and autonomy. Follow Tinsae on Twitter at @TinsaeAregay for daily Tesla news.