Skip to main content

Elon Musk Criticizes Proposed US EV Tax Credit Saying It Was Written By Ford & UWA Lobbyists

Elon Musk let his frustration out about the new EV tax credit saying it was written by Ford/UAW lobbyists, as they make their electric car in Mexico. Musk says the way the new rule is written does not serve the US taxpayer.


House Democrats in the US Congress have proposed a new electric car incentive program as part of a $3.5 trillion social spending bill.

The proposed overhaul of the EV tax incentive program, among several changes, increases the maximum tax break from the current $7,500 to $12,500.

The new proposed bill will also do away with the 200,000 vehicle limit set by the current federal EV tax incentive. Currently, electric vehicle buyers only get access to the $7,500 tax incentive, only until the auto OEM they are purchasing their vehicle from sells 200,000 EVs.

After the 200,000 mark is hit, the tax break gets halved every six months until the automakers’ customers no longer have access to the tax break. Currently, the 2 pioneering US EV makers, Tesla and GM, after selling 200,000 EVs, no longer have access to the federal EV tax break.

However, the new proposed EV tax incentive program, making its way through the legislative process looks to remove the 200,000 vehicles hard cap and replace it with a 5-year and 10-year deadline. 5 years for imported vehicles and 10 years for US-made vehicles.

Related news: Tesla Releases Mind-Blowing FSD V10

The new rule also looks to make the $12,500 rebate available to EV buyers at the point of sale. This means EV buyers will pay $12,500 less than the vehicle’s sticker price when they purchase a vehicle. This is as opposed to the current EV tax incentive where buyers pay the full price and get $7,500 as a rebate on their tax returns.

All the above-mentioned changes are commendable and will undoubtedly go a long way to accelerate electric vehicle adoption in the US. The new rules will also help EV pioneering companies like Tesla and GM which no longer have access to the $7,500 tax break.

However, the new rules are not without their caveats. And Tesla CEO Elon Musk believes these caveats were tailor-made by legacy auto and their unions to protect their self-interests.

Two of the caveats Musk took particular issue with are, first, $4,500 from the total $12,500 incentive has been reserved to EVs built-in unionized factories and second $500 is reserved for EVs using battery packs with 50% of components made in the US.

Tesla builds a significant portion of its battery pack in-house and in the US so the second stipulation shouldn’t be a problem however, Tesla factories are not unionized meaning Tesla vehicles will only qualify for an $8,000 incentive from the available total of $12,500.

Related news: Big Shift Is Happening With Tesla 4680 Battery Production

In response to Whole Mars Catalog, who lamented the Democrats’ decision to expand the union stipulation part of the incentive to $4,500 from an earlier chatter of $2,500, Musk said the stipulation was “written by Ford/UAW [United Auto Workers Union] lobbyists, as they make their electric car in Mexico. Not obvious how this serves American taxpayers.”

Musk also linked a Bloomberg article showing how Ford sells more Mustang Mach-Es from its Mexico plant than other Mustangs built at its Michigan plant.

Elon Musk believes if the EV tax incentive passes the way it’s written now, it will incentivize auto manufacturing to move from the US to Mexico and China. In order to avoid this outcome, Musk says the portion of the incentive reserved for US-made vehicles should be increased from $500, and at the same time, the part of the incentive reserved for unions should be decreased from $4,500.

As of now, Musk has not gotten a response from any concerned party regarding his concerns however, we will be sure to keep you posted if we hear more information. Make sure to visit our site regularly for the latest information.

So what do you think? Will the new tax incentive hurt Tesla? Let me know your thoughts down in the comments below.

For more information check out: This Is How Tesla Can Succeed in India Also, see What Are These Tesla Giga Castings Doing Outside at Fremont?

Tinsae Aregay has been following Tesla and The evolution of the EV space on a daily basis for several years. He covers everything about Tesla from the cars to Elon Musk, the energy business, and autonomy. Follow Tinsae on Twitter at @TinsaeAregay for daily Tesla news.


Timothy Boyer    September 13, 2021 - 10:55AM

In reply to by John Goreham

That is a very good rhetorical question. What does this really mean for lower income vehicle owners who cannot---or will not---become the EV-industry's iPhone equivalent customer? Corruption? Probably, but it is small potatoes compared to bigger issues in life. If the move toward EV's is really about making the world Greener---which, I have my doubts about being the true motivation behind the EV movement---I would like to know if these tax credits help lower-income car owners more than it hurts specialty-trending vehicle businesses?