Skip to main content

Ram 1500 vs. Toyota Tundra: The $65,000 Mistake You Won’t See Until the Warranty Expires

It looks like an easy choice in the showroom, but the math changes fast. See which $65,000 truck, Ram 1500 vs. Toyota Tundra, becomes a financial liability the moment the warranty expires.
Posted:
Author: Denis Flierl

Advertising

Advertising

Key Takeaways

  • Pick Your Poison: Toyota has had major mechanical failures (engines), while Ram suffers from chronic electrical annoyances.
  • The $7,700 Gap: Over 5 years, the Tundra is projected to cost nearly $8,000 less to own than the Ram, mainly due to depreciation and maintenance costs.
  • Resale King: If you trade in your trucks often, the Tundra’s high residual value offsets its initial lack of features.

In the showroom, the Ram 1500 dazzles with superior tech and luxury. But what happens when the warranty expires? We analyze the long-term costs of the Tundra’s engine recall drama versus the Ram’s electrical gremlins to determine which $65,000 truck is actually the safer bet for your wallet.

We have established that for $65,000, the Ram 1500 offers a more luxurious, feature-rich interior than the Toyota Tundra. If you buy a truck for the daily commute, the Ram wins the "showroom test" hands down.

But trucks aren't just bought for today; they are bought for the long haul. And this is where the math changes.

When you look at the 5-year cost of ownership and reliability trends for 2024-2026 models, the "boring" Toyota Tundra begins to make a compelling financial case for itself, despite its missing gadgets. Here is the reality of what it costs to own these two trucks once the new car smell fades.

The Toyota "Catastrophe" vs. The Ram "Death by a Thousand Cuts"

Reliability for these two trucks comes down to two very different types of headaches.

The Toyota Tundra has faced a headline-grabbing crisis: the twin-turbo V6 engine recall. Thousands of 2022-2024 (and potentially some 2025) models were flagged for machining debris that could cause total engine failure.

The Reality: This is a catastrophic but solvable issue. If your engine fails, Toyota is replacing the entire long block. It is a massive inconvenience, but once fixed, the truck is mechanically sound. The rest of the truck—transmission, electronics, suspension—remains robust.

The Ram 1500, specifically with the new "Hurricane" Inline-6, faces a different enemy: Electrical Gremlins.

The Reality: Owners of 2025-2026 models are reporting less catastrophic but far more annoying issues. Common complaints include instrument clusters freezing, battery drain caused by "parasitic" modules that won't sleep, and collision-avoidance systems acting up. Unlike a blown engine, these intermittent electrical ghosts are notoriously hard to diagnose and fix permanently, leading to the dreaded "could not replicate" service ticket.

The Financials: 5-Year Cost to Own

According to recent data from Kelley Blue Book (KBB) and insurance analysts, the "Toyota Tax" is real—but it pays you back.

2025 Toyota Tundra in the driveway

2025/2026 Toyota Tundra Limited:

Advertising


5-Year Cost to Own: ~$57,700

Depreciation: Toyota consistently retains a higher resale value. A Tundra with 100k miles is still viewed as "just broken in" by the market.

2025 Ram 1500 Laramie on the dealer's lot

2025/2026 Ram 1500 Laramie:

5-Year Cost to Own: ~$65,400

Depreciation: Ram trucks depreciate more quickly, partly due to perceptions of long-term electrical reliability. That air suspension that feels amazing today? It is a costly repair waiting to happen at 120,000 miles.

The Verdict: 

If you plan to keep the truck for 3-4 years (or lease), buy the Ram 1500. You get the better ride, the better screen, and the better tailgate, and you will be under warranty for any electrical issues. You are paying for the experience, and it is arguably better.

If you plan to keep the truck for 10 years / 200,000 miles, buy the Toyota Tundra. Yes, you miss out on the passenger screen. Yes, the engine recall history is scary. But a Toyota with a replaced factory engine is still likely to have fewer electrical demons at year 7 than a Ram with an aging complex architecture.

What Do You Think?

Would you rather deal with a one-time major engine repair (covered by warranty) or years of intermittent electrical glitches? Does the Ram’s luxury justify the higher long-term cost? Let us know in the comments below.

Read More from Denis Flierl:

Click the red link below to write your comment and join the community in sharing experiences.

With over 30 years of industry experience, Denis Flierl brings an insider’s perspective to Torque News, where he has been a Senior Reporter since 2012. Before picking up the pen, Denis consulted for the automotive industry's biggest brands and honed his skills as a test driver. He cuts through the noise to deliver the latest auto news, compelling owner stories, and the expert analysis necessary to navigate today's changing automotive market.

Have a tip or question? Follow me on X @DenisFlierl and @WorldsCoolestRides, or connect with me on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.

Photo credit: Denis Flierl

Google preferred badge

Advertising

Comments

Ok...Only Ram 2500 Series…

Anthony B. (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 2:17PM

Ok...Only Ram 2500 Series With 6.4 Hemi.....The Ram 1500 Series..5.7 Hemi Problems With Cam/ Lifter Failures...Hurricane 6 Cylinder Twin Turbo..You Need Extended Warranty...The 6.4 Hemi Ram 2500 Series Is The Best Choice....


Advertising


I don't know much about the…

nogoslo (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 3:03PM

I don't know much about the replacement Toyota engines, but it has been reported that the problem Chevy/GMC V8 and minimax diesel engines are being replaced with new ones, and those fail with the same problems.

I tend to keep my vehicles a…

Charles M (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 3:26PM

I tend to keep my vehicles a long time. I don't need a lot of electronics.
Knobs and buttons are great, touchscreens suck when driving.
My needs: Radio, satellite and Bluetooth are nice but not required.
A/C, heat and cool me, fancy controls not needed.
Go when I want, stop when I want.
Easy repairs, sorry Toyota but twin turbos don't sound easy to repair or maintain.
I would still go with the Toyota but would prefer a non turbo engine.

I would not buy anything new…

Aaron watts (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 4:28PM

I would not buy anything new.iam old and cheep.happy 23y old Tacoma 4 Dr try 4x4 200,000 just replaced 3 belts .runs great .run another 100,000 miles.

You might not have a choice…

Squeaky Wheel (not verified)    December 15, 2025 - 10:49AM

In reply to by Aaron watts (not verified)

You might not have a choice if your ancient tacoma gets stolen or totaled.

The new Gen 3 Tundras…

Jacketman (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 4:30PM

The new Gen 3 Tundras depreciate like a rock

My $60k 2022 with 27k miles has a KBB of 38k . That is a $20k hit from my drive out in 40 months

I've owned 3 Toyota Tacomas…

Jim Martin (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 7:22PM

I've owned 3 Toyota Tacomas and I'm now on my 2nd ram 1500. The first ram, 2019, went 160000 miles with no problems. My 2nd one, 2024, is coming up on 30000 miles. The only problem I have had is the u connect, an electric pile of junk that's been replaced once and coming up on another replacement. Toy in my opinion has fallen in quality to the level of GMC. I'll stay with my rams.

Or you get a Tundra with the…

Kurt Kawczynski (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 8:33PM

Or you get a Tundra with the V8 and it will run for a very long time.

Never mind the national…

Brian Morton (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 8:33PM

Never mind the national recall for 2022-2024 Tundra engines. NHTSA campaign numbers 24V-381 and 25TB14/25TA14. Owners of 2025 models have reported similar issues, but they aren't included in the recall. I wouldn't touch a Toyota Tundra made after 2022 with a ten-foot pole.

Ford F150 is the best truck…

Rafaelle Berlingieri (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 8:34PM

Ford F150 is the best truck you can buy. I am on my 4th with minimal costs and great resale with over 130-150k miles. My latest 2016 is coming up with 150k with the 2.7l twin turbo. It’s been the most solid of them all.

I'm still on my first Ram…

Brian Payne (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 12:57PM

In reply to by Rafaelle Berlingieri (not verified)

I'm still on my first Ram 1500 Big Horn. I wouldn't own another Ford 150. I had a Ford years ago with the online 6, 4.9l. Great truck than they switched to the v8 302. I'll stay with Ram for now.

2017 Tundra. Best truck I…

Denis Lindberg (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 8:34PM

2017 Tundra. Best truck I ever owned. I should have my head examined for selling it.

I have a 2000 Tundra with…

Dave (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 10:02PM

In reply to by Denis Lindberg (not verified)

I have a 2000 Tundra with 290;000 miles. Replaced a starter 3 timing belts,my radiator and that is it. All original except brake pads. Original rotors too. Best vehicle I have ever owned with an antique tag too. New trucks are fragile today say the least. Buyer beware

I would by a certified pre…

George Bruce (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 8:35PM

I would by a certified pre owned Tundra with the 5.7L; their foray into twin turbo 6 platform has been a disaster.

Nothing is a better truck…

Helmut Straner (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 8:36PM

Nothing is a better truck when you buy a RAM. Its an expensive trash container on wheels that makes lots of noise.

My 2014 RAM 1500 has ~150…

Ian Haynes (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 8:36PM

My 2014 RAM 1500 has ~150,000 miles, eight Canadian winters and three cross-country trips (two of which were towing another vehicle) on it. It's had its share of issues but, so far, none of the engine issues.

I would avoid the RAMs with…

Mike Mccormick (not verified)    December 12, 2025 - 8:45PM

I would avoid the RAMs with the 3.0 twin turbo. That engine will randomly blow out cats or have thermostat issues. I've replaced many of them. Glad they are going back to the 5.7L V8's

The only options for any…

Todd Frazier (not verified)    December 13, 2025 - 7:19AM

The only options for any patriotic American should be the ones paying U.A.W. wages collectively bargained for.......not the substandard wages and throat cutting non union, non American ones.

Now if only the Toyota wasn…

John (not verified)    December 13, 2025 - 9:03AM

Now if only the Toyota wasn't so ugly. I mean god that thing would scare the kids. And those stupid center stack screens that look like a 10 year old crazy glued it to the dash. What ever happened to designers who actually knew how to integrate things. Oh wait there are trucks that do have dashes that are properly designed.

Interesting story but you…

Jmax (not verified)    December 13, 2025 - 11:21AM

Interesting story but you forgot my dynamic . We are older folks getting ready to reload for one last time and we don’t drive very much so what’s best now ?

What isn't widely known is…

Doug (not verified)    December 13, 2025 - 1:36PM

What isn't widely known is that Mopar offers an lifetime & unlimited mile warranty for $2500.

I was offered this by mopar a week after I rolled my 2018 (1500 Tungsten) off the lot. When I log into my mymopar.com it shows 100 years and unlimited miles and covers bumper-to-bumper for factory parts.

My suspension is no longer covered due to a lift I installed but it covered the infotainment unit ($1200) when the touchscreen delaminated itself.

As long as I stay on my maintenance schedule, engine, transmission, diff is all covered.. and electrical.

Just food for thought for those who are contemplating a RAM.

Bought the tundra sr5 crew…

MICHAEL (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 2:06AM

Bought the tundra sr5 crew and sit at about 5500 mi. I'd like to see better milage . It may even out later. The power is nice.
We took it on a 1600 mi. Trip and it was so comfortable and quite.
The ride is amazing with the system they have.
I am waiting to pull our trailer next summer. I pulled it once from the shop to home and ran a steep hill as a test. RPMs never moved so smooth I was shocked.
Had 2005 Dodge diesel 2500 with 3 speed. It pulled the same hill without shifting but any steeper and it would have.

My second vehicle is one I…

Lorne Tuplin (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 10:18AM

My second vehicle is one I looked for for about 40 years. It was worth the wait. I bought it 5 years ago with 121,000 km on it. It now has 131,000 km on it and I have had a few repairs done on it but for a 1987 Dodge Dakota 3.9 V6, 4 wheel drive I think it has done well! Transmission is a bit rough going into drive but it keeps doing it. I paid $2,300 for it spent a few thousand on it including having the faded 80's paint professionally redone, but current appraised value sits at $15,000.

how pathetic that $65k…

winifred mulvey (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 10:28AM

how pathetic that $65k trucks that SHOULD be reliable over the long haul aren't.. doesn't matter which brand , they are all disposable garbage..

I have a 2016 Toyota Tundra…

Barry Helferty (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 10:48AM

I have a 2016 Toyota Tundra 5.7 L. After 9 yrs the only cost has been oil changes, tires a battery and brakes. I'm not sold on the new Tundra with a V6 twin turbo but I do swear by Toyota's quality and longevity. I don't think I'd buy anything else again.

Engine? Annoying messages? I…

mark (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 2:14PM

Engine?
Annoying messages?
I think I will be annoyed and comfortable!
oh and much better lookin

I'd go with the Ram. Alot of…

Gino Mutz (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 8:25PM

I'd go with the Ram. Alot of the replaced engines are also failing. These twin turbo engines have design flaws which keep causing these engines to fail. This issue with these engines has been going on since 2022 and we're in 2025 with the same issues! It's obvious that they haven't fixed the issue with this engines and who knows if they ever will!

You want a real RAM gremlin …

Seab43 (not verified)    December 14, 2025 - 8:53PM

You want a real RAM gremlin !?
I own a 2014 RAM Tradesman 1500 gas V6 .
125,000 miles .
Needs an ABS module . Backorders are one year I'm told !
Otherwise truck runs great except for those annoying lites !
Very hesitant to buy any other RAM/Chrysler products.
Another negative, to replace the oil pressure & oil temperature sensors you have to remove the oil filter/oil cooler assembly . Two $35-40 sensors cost hundreds to replace. Engineering joke !

First off, the Toyota engine…

Paul (not verified)    December 16, 2025 - 7:27AM

First off, the Toyota engine failures are caused by a faulty main bearing, and not “machining debris “. Secondly, there have been reports of “replacement “ engines grenading from the same issue. I am in no means a fan of Dodge (dictionary meaning :to avoid), but Toyota has lost much of its reliability reputation, at least to me.