I Traded Two Model Ys For An Ioniq 6 And A Used Bolt, I’m Getting Better Range For Less Money And My Insurance Is Cheaper

Tesla, once the shimmering apex predator of the electric ecosystem, now finds itself in the awkward position of being a car company, a loud one, certainly, and still capable of turning heads, but no longer the only EV worth writing home about. What was once a near-religious experience for owners is starting to feel like a fading brand loyalty campaign, a Super Bowl ad stretched across an entire ownership cycle. Across Reddit, forums, and real-world parking lots, the bloom is off the rose.

A Reddit user, lightofhonor, decided to do what had to be done, ditch two Tesla Model Ys, and swap them for a Hyundai Ioniq 6 and a used Chevy Bolt, and walk away happy. Not just content, happy.

Swapping Out My Model Ys

“Had two Model Ys but didn't want to keep them, and they were depreciating before our eyes as we checked the prices, so I bit the bullet and swapped out both. Had varying amounts of equity in the cars, but got what we could that would match our realistic needs. Bittersweet, but one less thing we needed to think about!” 

What makes this story more than just another Reddit anecdote is what came next: a wave of support. Reddit threads typically resemble back-alley knife fights more than barroom conversations, but this one was filled with empathy, agreement, and shared exhaustion. As one user put it, 

“Don’t lose money over it… OP did what was best for him, so don’t feel peer pressured.” 

There’s your twist: in a forum notorious for infighting and brand tribalism, people actually agreed not just about the financials, but also about the values behind the wheel.

Tesla Owners Are Trading In Their Cars

• Data from Edmunds indicates that Tesla trade-ins have increased by 250% year-over-year, with vehicles from model year 2017 or newer accounting for 1.4% of all trade-ins through mid-March, up from 0.4% the previous year. ​
• Factors such as concerns over vehicle depreciation, increased market saturation, and CEO Elon Musk's heightened political involvement have led to a decline in brand loyalty among Tesla owners. ​
• Many former Tesla owners are opting for electric vehicles from legacy automakers, attracted by competitive pricing, new technology, and a desire to distance themselves from Tesla's recent controversies.

And those values are shifting. The Ioniq 6, though technically down 40 miles of rated range compared to the Model Y, delivered better battery efficiency in a real-world 80-mile drive. 

“The Ioniq used less of the battery percentage.” 

Said lightofhonor, despite Hyundai quoting a more conservative EPA number. That speaks volumes about how drivers are starting to prioritize the right metrics.

Quietness, build quality, efficiency in daily driving, factors that were once secondary to 0-60 times and Supercharger maps are now at the front of the conversation.

Trading In For A Chevy Bolt

Then there's the Bolt. Yes, it’s plasticky. Yes, it smells vaguely of an economy car. But it works. For a two-mile commute, it’s perfect, unpretentious, inexpensive, and immune to the kind of ideological drama that now trails Tesla like road salt in spring. 

"Used bolts are crazy cheap!" 

The Redditor noted. And while nobody’s nominating it for design awards, it’s a case study in utility winning out over flash. For people who actually need a car, instead of something to pose in next to a rooftop solar panel, the Bolt is suddenly relevant again.

Of course, not everyone can make the jump. Commenters lamented negative equity, job insecurity, and the sheer cost of change. 

“I’d love to swap mine as well, but I’ve got around $10K in negative equity,” 

One user wrote. The irony? These were the same customers Tesla courted with big dreams and tech wizardry, only to leave them holding the bag as prices dropped and resale values tanked. The Reddit consensus? It’s not that the cars are bad. It’s that they’re not special anymore. Not when the same features are now baked into rivals with better build quality and more modest CEOs.

The Tesla Depreciation Curve

• Tesla vehicles have been reported to depreciate significantly, with some studies indicating a depreciation of approximately 28.9% year-over-year. This rate is notably higher than many other automotive brands. ​
• Different Tesla models exhibit varying depreciation rates. For instance, the Model 3 has a five-year depreciation rate of around 42.9%, while the Model S depreciates approximately 55.5% over the same period. These figures highlight the disparities in value retention among Tesla's lineup. ​
• Several factors contribute to Tesla's depreciation trends, including frequent price adjustments, rapid technological advancements, and shifts in consumer preferences. These elements can impact the resale value and overall market perception of Tesla vehicles.

Speaking of which, the Musk Effect looms large here. While some commenters, like Michael-Brady-99, stood by Tesla and its original mission, others pointed to Elon’s increasingly unpredictable behavior as a reason to walk away entirely. 

“You don't want to lose value/money because of Musk's antics.” 

Another wrote, hitting the nail square on its memeable head. Tesla isn’t just a car company, it’s a personality cult. And for many, the cost of membership is getting too high.

So here we are. A brand that once defined the future is now just part of it. Meanwhile, legacy automakers. The very companies Tesla once scoffed at are quietly, competently making EVs that work. The Ioniq 6. The Bolt. Maybe even the EV9 or the Mach-E, if you squint a bit. The market is growing. Tesla made the EV mainstream, yes, but the mainstream has caught up, and it’s bringing better insurance rates, quieter cabins, and door pockets big enough for water bottles. Now that’s progress.

Have you parted ways with your Tesla Model Y yet? Did you cash out big or take a painful hit, and what's your new ride? Drop your story in the comments below

Image Sources:  Tesla Media Center, Hyundai Media Center

Noah Washington is an automotive journalist based in Atlanta, Georgia. He enjoys covering the latest news in the automotive industry and conducting reviews on the latest cars. He has been in the automotive industry since 15 years old and has been featured in prominent automotive news sites. You can reach him on X and LinkedIn for tips and to follow his automotive coverage.