Electric Cars Charging 200-900 size nissan leaf toyota prius plug in

The Difference Between The Hybrid EV, Extended Range EV and Fully Electric EV

Let's remove the riddle of EV cars and help people to select between different types of EVs such as the Hybrid EV, Extended Range EV and the Fully Electric EV.
Advertisement


Recently began looking for a new car and decided to investigate the EVs. Unfortunately, the industry has yet to implemented clearly defined markers for comparison purposes. My goal here is to explain how I came to select an EV car. I’m very happy how everything worked out and believe I made a good technical and financial decision based on my needs. I hope this helps you and perhaps you can add your own decisions formulas.

So, these cars come in 3 main configurations.

Hybrid EV vs Extended Range EV vs Fully Electric EV

Hybrid EV, a gas engine driven car that also powers a small generator. The electric motors assist and or powers vehicle directly through the common mechanical drivetrain. Great for city, limited electric range and comes with no plug-in charging. When gas runs out this unit will be limited in range and speed automatically drops down. Hybrids Explained - What’s a Plug-in, a Mild, or an ER-EV?

Extended Range EV is a full electric car with an on-board generator. It solely operates on electric and can generate electric power to store in the battery through its on-board gas engine generator. Because of greater battery capacity over the Hybrids it offers longer (electric only) commutes and has a L2 plugged in port. Braking forces regenerate battery, and when gas runs out this unit will be limited in range only. In fact, you can add 40 miles driving range to Nissan Leaf with Enginer's add-on battery pack.

Fully Electric EV is a battery only car. Great for even longer (electric only) commuting and requires to be plugged in. Braking forces regenerate battery, since this does not use gas, its range is limited by battery capacity.

In my location the government offers rebates based on how green and what price range your EV locates. I’m sure there are other criteria. So, based on my daily commute of 80 miles and budget, I decided on the Extended Range EV. Now the concern is how to select the right car with no datum to work from. I found the dealers to be wishy washy on performance, so I made my own formula. Keeping in mind I have a good commute. I started with the Volt and looked as much information as I could find at its competitors. This was the type of information I could gather.

What I found is as the engine size goes up the battery capacity goes down.

  • Year - 2018
  • Model - Volt
  • Battery Capacity kWh - 18.4
  • Engine Size - 1.5L
  • Battery Regeneration - Yes

What I could readily identify for all Extended Range EV cars was battery capacity. This is a gem of intelligence because one can now compare EVs on a level playing field. One could also determine electric range and costs to operate fully electric. The formula is a rule of thumb only as I cannot determine any peripheral electronic consumers.

It takes about 15 HP for a midsize car to main 60 mph. That means no external forces added and at a nominally mild temperature. Wind and cold would lower performance. Using this for all vehicles should provide for a pretty good comparison point. (Rule of Thumb only)

Volt battery capacity is 18.4 which is 25 hp/hr. The hp required to maintain 60 mph is 15, so 25/15 = time of driving at 60 mph = 1.7 hours. This was the highest result I could find in all my EV car comparison. Distance driven is 60 x 1.7 = 102 miles, albeit this is obtainable with influences like regenerative braking, long steady declines and slow speeds.

To take this a step further, our electric charge costs are 7.7 cents per kWh during off peak times. Therefor the cost to charge battery is 7.7 x 18.4 = $1.42.

I hope with this technical review this may help you select your Ev. Also see: Is Chevy Volt an EV, Hybrid or Both?


Sign-up to our email newsletter for daily perspectives on car design, trends, events and news, not found elsewhere.

Comments

Your math doesn't work with the units you've defined. Please explain: 25hp/hr divided by 15 hp = 1.7 __/hr. I believe you intend to say car requires 15 hp/hr to maintain 60mph. 18.4 kW = 25hp. Then your equation works: 25hp/(15hp/hr)=1.7hr
Yes, units should be hp/hr. Very sorry about that and thank you for pointing that out.
great posting John, I love My Prius's , my 07 just gave me the big bad salute from the hybrid batteries! 213,000 abused miles and she still is on factory regenerative brakes! For how this vehicle was driven like a V-8 it's probably more realistic to 300k miles on the drive train! That being said, I would also say that one would want to figure in upkeep on various vehicles find out what the real bargain is! I can't imagine dollar for dollar beating Toyota 's reliability and economy! While I talk w/Chevy Volt owners and have been told they only Lease them so the problems are passed on to another owner down the uhhhh Road! Moving a bunch of items from Montana to Cal something blocked the vent for Inverter Cooler, so I had that replaced in Utah at a Toyota Dealership where a Mechanic had same year 2nd Generation Prius w/over 600,000 miles on it, meticulously kept up! Sure I would love to see the list of repairs he's done to it in the past 11 years! Anyway, I'm off track, loved your Article... I don't buy into the 100+mpge mileage they boast! I've been to the gas station w/friends to see their cars computer say more realistic 37-39 in fuel usage! So please explain top folks the mpgE so they realize its really not miles per gallon and Please emphasize there is a cost and hassle w/Electricity as well! .... God Bless America