Skip to main content

Consumer Reports Recommends These Cars as the Most Reliable New Midsized Sedans

Here are the latest recommendations from Consumer Reports analysts for car shoppers looking for reasonably priced sedans that not only rate among the best when it comes to fuel efficiency but are also rated very reliable in comparison to many other sedans that do not always prove to be as reliable.

Fuel Efficiency, Space…and Reliability
Fuel efficiency and cargo space are big selling points for new car sedan shoppers who do not want to buy an SUV. However, the most important selling point regardless of the vehicle type is that of reliability; Especially, to ensure that the new vehicle owner does not wind up stranded on the road, pay exorbitant repair costs, and be without wheels for two weeks or more waiting on parts and repairs.

The good news is that in a recent post-Thanksgiving Consumer Reports’ newsletter, car shoppers are alerted to a selection of what their analysts recommend as the most reliable sedans you can buy today with a focus on gas mileage, cargo space, and reliability in new models of midsized cars.

Related article: New Vehicles That Cost the Most to Fuel and Used Vehicles That are the Most Fuel Efficient

That said, here is a summary of their list of the most reliable midsized sedans they recommend to assist you in finding the model you need today. Please note that data regarding mileage and overall vehicle rating are not available on the latest Honda Accord models due to "not tested" at this time by CR analysts.

Most Reliable Midsized Sedans

2023 Toyota Camry Hybrid
Price Range: $25,945 - $36,370
CR MPG: Overall 47 / City 39 / Hwy 53 mpg
Rated #1 of 14 Midsized cars

Predicted Reliability Score: 4/5
Predicted Owner Satisfaction Score: 4/5

2023 Honda Accord Hybrid
Price Range: $27,720 - $37,590

Predicted Reliability Score: 4/5
Predicted Owner Satisfaction Score: 4/5

2023 Honda Accord
Price Range: $26,520 - $38,450

Predicted Reliability Score: 4/5
Predicted Owner Satisfaction Score: 3/5 due primarily due to customer value estimations of what they got for the price paid.

2023 Lexus ES Hybrid
Price Range: $41,020
CR MPG: Overall 42 / City 32 / Hwy 52 mpg
Rated #1 of 14 Luxury midsized cars

Predicted Reliability Score: 4/5
Predicted Owner Satisfaction Score: 4/5

2023 Toyota Camry (Non-Hybrid model)
Price Range: $25,945 - $36,370
CR MPG: Overall 32 / City 20 / Hwy 49 mpg
Rated #5 of 14 Midsized cars

Predicted Reliability Score: 4/5
Predicted Owner Satisfaction Score: 4/5

2023 Nissan Altima
Price Range: $25,290 - $34,990
CR MPG: Overall 31 / City 20 / Hwy 45 mpg
Rated #4 of 14 Midsized cars

Predicted Reliability Score: 4/5
Predicted Owner Satisfaction Score: 2/5 due to marginal low customer ratings on comfort and value respectively led to a lowered predicted owner satisfaction rating.

2023 Kia K5
Price Range: $25,090 - $31,490
CR MPG: Overall 32 / City 20 / Hwy 52 mpg
Rated #6 of 14 Midsized cars

Predicted Reliability Score: 4/5
Predicted Owner Satisfaction Score: 3/5 due primarily due to customer value estimations of what they got for the price paid.

2023 Hyundai Sonata
Price Range: $24,950 - $34,975
CR MPG: Overall 31 / City 20 / Hwy 46 mpg
Rated #7 of 14 Midsized cars

Predicted Reliability Score: 4/5
Predicted Owner Satisfaction Score: 3/5 due primarily due to customer value estimations of what they got for the price paid.

For a more detailed breakdown of the data, please visit the CR website. Note that while access to some information requires a CR membership, the potential savings make it negligible in comparison when looking for the latest information to aid your car buying research.

And finally…

For additional CR-related new and used sedan recommendations, here are a few from this past year for your consideration and comparison shopping:

Consumer Reports Recommends These Midsized Sedans Under $20,000 with the Best Fuel Economy

Consumer Reports Best New Car Deals for 2022 Sedans

Consumer Reports New Car Winners and Losers for This Important Safety Feature

COMING UP NEXT: The Biggest Car Buying Mistakes You Can Make with a Dealership

Timothy Boyer is a Torque News automotive reporter based in Cincinnati. Experienced with early car restorations, he regularly restores older vehicles with engine modifications for improved performance. Follow Tim on Twitter at @TimBoyerWrites for daily new and used vehicle news.

Image Source: Pixabay