Skip to main content

New Honda Passport Two-Row Crossover Tops All Rivals In Comparison Testing

The new Honda Pilot just bested the Ford Edge, Nissan Murano, Chevrolet Blazer, and Hyundai Santa Fe. Here's what Car and Driver found.

Honda's new Passport just proved itself superior to the best in the two-row crossover segment. In a comprehensive comparison test, the new Passport rose to the top in many objective categories and also won the hearts and minds of testers. What is most interesting is that the three-row Honda Pilot, which shares a lot of its parts with the Passport, finished last in a Car and Driver (CD) comparison not too long ago.

We won't spoil too much of the CD comparison test, but the aging Nissan Rogue finished last. CD's staffers found the engine "raucous," didn't like the CVT (because the secretly all want to drive stick shift 1990 BMW 3 Series cars) and found the space inefficiency of the Murano a big negative (we have to agree). However, the Murano did have the best overall ride of the group.

The price tags of the vehicles compared ranged from just under $40K for the Hyundai Santa Fe Ultimate AWD, to a whopping $50,765 for the new Chevy Blazer. The Honda Passport Elite AWD was almost exactly in the middle of the pack with a price of $45,695.

Watch one thing you can do with Honda Passport that you can't do with most other cars and click to subscribe to Torque News Youtube Channel for daily Honda and automotive news analysis.

This price includes a modern V6 engine. Although some of the competitors had 2.0-liter turbocharged engines, the Honda Passport had the fastest acceleration time and the fastest passing time in the group. Add to that the best real-world MPG as well and you can see that small four-cylinder turbos really don't match the power and efficiency of a good V6.

CD liked that the Passport was big on space and drive small. The summary of the verdict said that the Honda Passport had, "The best combination of utility and driving pleasure also comes with a reasonable price tag."

Torque News hopes to have a chance to do a full test on the Pilot soon and will bring you our conclusions. Based on our first drive, we are pretty sure we will be in agreement with the folks at Car and Driver.


Mark Day (not verified)    May 9, 2019 - 7:07PM

In reply to by J P (not verified)

Never would have guessed that Honda uses a timing BELT on an interference engine. Do manufactures, like Honda, make sure to design their vehicles with at least one major flaw - seems so. The belt issue is enough for me to declare - no sale.

Bruce (not verified)    May 9, 2019 - 7:04PM

Excited to ride in the Passport but wonder why Honda didn't bring back an updated Element instead. They were a true utility crossover that is sorely missed in today's cookie cutter SUV market.

RMV (not verified)    May 31, 2019 - 7:43PM

Our 2004 Honda Element EX is still going strong with 112K miles on it. We haul bikes, dogs, and kayaks; camp in and with it, and have taken multi week road trips in it. I’ve cross-shopped everything on the market and can’t find a decent substitute. I’d love to have Carplay and safety features but I guess I’m driving it until it falls apart!