Even as American families grow smaller, the demand for three-row SUVs grows larger: especially affordable models like the Hyundai Palisade and the Subaru Ascent. Which is the better choice – the Subaru or the Hyundai? Let’s take a look at the numbers and a couple of subjective points.
Why lead with reliability? It’s a point that too many consumers don’t put enough stock in. They get caught up in the sexiness of powertrains and infotainment systems. Yet, at the end of the day, you want a vehicle that’s going to be in your driveway and not at the service center.
Our Subaru expert Denis Flierl recently wrote about the Subaru Ascent’s reliability. It’s not good to be on a 10 worst list. Denis reports the Ascent 3-Row SUV initially had average reliability, but recent transmission problems, sometimes requiring a replacement, have lowered its reliability score.
The research for the Subaru Ascent came from Consumer Reports, which assigned it a reliability score of 18. The Hyundai Palisade, by comparison, has a score of 65 but its predicted reliability score is 4 out of 5. The 2021 Ascent is scored at 1 out of 5.
The Hyundai Palisade is more reliable than the Subaru Ascent.
OK, so it’s time to address the sexiness of the powertrain. The Subaru Ascent is powered by an all-new FA24 2.4-liter turbocharged Boxer engine developed just for the new three-row family hauler. It comes with 260 horsepower and 277 lb-ft of torque. Power is sent to all four wheels through a continuously variable automatic transmission (CVT).
The Hyundai Palisade’s power comes from an Atkinson-cycle 3.8-liter V6, dual CVVT, direct-injected engine with 291 horsepower and 262 lb-ft of torque. Palisade delivers that power to the wheels via an eight-speed automatic transmission. The Palisade with AWD weighs 150 pounds less than the Ascent, which in my humble opinion, makes the torque numbers a relative draw.
Also, the Palisade has a tow rating of 5,000 pounds. The Ascent is rated at 2,000 pounds.
Comparing apples to apples, the Palisade with AWD gets a combined 21 mpg, according to the EPA. The Ascent, which only comes in AWD, is scored at 23 mpg.
The tiebreaker for me is the Ascent has a CVT while the Palisade has an eight-speed automatic. Under full loads, the Palisade is going to be smoother and its larger engine won’t strain as much under acceleration. The Palisade is the better choice for its powertrain.
It’s tough to argue against safety when it comes to Subaru. It’s one of the hallmarks of the brand. The standard EyeSight Driver Assist Technology alone makes it a compelling choice. For 2021, the EyeSight adds advanced adaptive cruise control with lane centering and lane keep assist.
The Palisade offers a number of advanced safety technologies, including Forward Collision-Avoidance Assist with Pedestrian Detection, Blind Spot Collision-Avoidance Assist, Lane Following Assist, Rear Cross-Traffic Collision Avoidance Assist, Safe Exit Assist, High Beam Assist, Driver Attention Warning and Smart Cruise Control with Stop and Go.
Lets score the Subaru Ascent the winner when it comes to safety. Subaru continues to be the leader in this sector (but that by no means implies the Palisade is unsafe).
The Hyundai Palisade has two more cubic feet of passenger volume than the Subaru Ascent. While the Ascent has slightly more front-row headroom, the Palisade has a lot more front-row legroom, which was important to me as a six-footer. Where the Palisade really wins is second-row legroom, with a four-inch advantage. Grownups will like that extra space. Cargo numbers for both models are largely similar.
The interiors of both models are noted for their near luxury-levels of comfort. Both are suitable for long drives. Both have good infotainment systems as well.
Lets score the Ascent as having a slightly better interior just because of its looks. That’s entirely subjective and might be more of my Yankee sensitivities.
The Subaru Ascent with standard all-wheel drive has a base MSRP of $32,295. The Palisde with standard front-wheel drive is priced at $32,525. Throw in all-wheel drive and the price jumps to $34,225. According to this research from U.S. News, you’re more likely to find deals on Subarus with an average price of $30,785 for the Ascent versus $35,263 for the AWD Palisade.
On price alone, the Subaru Ascent is the clear better choice.
Based on the five areas focused on, the Hyundai Palisade is a better choice than the Ascent with the higher base MSRP. The ongoing reliability issue continues to be a concern. Plus, the Palisade has a more functional powertrain for hauling people and cargo combined.
Keith Griffin covers Hyundai and Kia at Torque News. He has been writing continuously about cars since 2002. Keith used to be a researcher/writer for US News & World Report, as well as numerous car sites, including Carfax and Car Gurus, and a contributor to The Boston Globe. Most recently, Keith was the managing editor for American Business Media. Follow Keith at @indepthauto on Twitter, on @LinkedIn and on his Indepth Auto Facebook page.