Tesla Model S
Armen Hareyan's picture

Man tests almost all EVs and Says Hybrids are "Garbage," Do You Agree?

I personally own a 2012 Toyota Prius, which I bought two weeks ago. I am very happy with it and think it's a great compromise between an electric car and a ICE. However, one man, who says he tried all EVs and Plug-in Hybrids, calls the hybrids as "garbage." As a hybrid owner I disagree with him. But let's share his reasoning. Here is Mathias Carlberg from Electric Cars Facebook Group.
Advertisement


I tested almost all EVs and plug-in hybrids in my market and talked to so many people with different hybrids, plug-in hybrids etc... and yes they are garbage!

For example the Audi A3 e-tron (same as the VW e-golf) has a range of 50 km. In reality its like 30 km. The Price? It's a lot more than a gas or diesel. Its a joke. Same with Mitshubishi.

The Nissan LEAF is in theory 120 km, but in reality you are lucky to get 100 km and in winter that means its a no go.

When you have to compromise how you drive its not an option anymore. Sure as a second car for just the city a Nissan LEAF would be OK. But as I said there is just one EV at the moment without compromise. Tesla!

Tesla is also the only US car that I really think is good. Sure quality of materials and details are not up to European standards, but "ok". The rest of the car is just brilliant. I hope BMW and Porsche get something similar out of the door. Model 3 will be a true game changer. While BMW and Porsche hunt model S. Tesla will release the model 3. Who with a brain will buy something else?

To this, a group member named Spectra Se replies and says.

When it comes to Nissan LEAF 100km is more than enough for 95% of my driving needs in the South. Though I can see how non-Tesla owners in the North may need ICE power in the winter. I don't buy the whole hybrid vs. BEV war. What matters is how much range you have on battery only power and is it enough for a vast majority of your needs. Yes, BEVs tend to have more battery-only range, but it's no guarantee (easy example, the Mitsubishi I-Miev, which has virtually no better battery-only range than the new Volt).


Sign-up to our email newsletter for daily perspectives on car design, trends, events and news, not found elsewhere.

Comments

100km Range is humilliating, carmakers want us back to middle ages (Same range as for a Milburn electric vehicle from the 1920´s). Carmakers pretend to convince us that modern technology is way worse than the one we used for the plomb-acid battery technology. What? the range with Lithium is worse than with plomb-acid batteries!!! Don´t you ever listen to someone saying that 100km range is adequate for 95% of transport needs. Crappy opinion even if true. Minimal range should be 350km at least.
wrong wrong. Leaf is 107 * 1.6 = 171 km according to the EPA. In 2017 Leaf will be 250 km. The best car is a SEV serial EV: 35 kWh or more battery, 80 kW or more motor, Range extender 20 kW or less. This is the magic formula and whoever does this first will dominate the market.